For those interested in demographics or economic trends, domestic migration — people moving from one county to another in the United States — offers a critical window to the future. Domestic migration, which excludes international migration and the natural increase of births in excess of deaths, tells us much about how people are voting — with their feet. Domestic migrants are also important because they generally arrive at their new residences with more resources than the average immigrant or newborn.
For decades, for example, people have been moving from the state of New York to just about everywhere else. In fact, since 2000, New York has bled more domestic migrants per capita than Louisiana after the devastation of Hurricane Katrina. While 7.8 percent of the Empire State’s 2000 population was packing, the nation’s worst disaster (natural and man-made) drove only 7.5 percent of Louisiana’s population away.
But New York’s story is an old one. The big surprise is how smaller sized metropolitan areas are now attracting a large share of movers. For generations Americans have crowded into ever larger metropolitan areas — including suburbs and exurbs — but more recently they have been heading to smaller regions. You could call it “sprawl beyond sprawl.”
Overall, between 2000 and 2007, U.S. Bureau of the Census data indicates that the metropolitan areas with more than 1,000,000 population in 2000 have lost two million domestic migrants, or 1.3 percent of their population. In contrast, smaller metropolitan areas — those with populations between 50,000 to 1,000,000 — gained 2.2 million domestic migrants, or 2.2 percent of their population. Smaller areas (under 50,000, including rural areas) also gained, attracting 700,000 domestic migrants, or 1.6 percent of their population.
But the real the growth is concentrated not in small towns but among the metropolitan areas between 100,000 and 500,000 population. Overall, these medium sized metropolitan areas added 1.6 million domestic migrants — a very healthy 7.6 percent of their population.
Among the nearly 500 metropolitan areas in this category, 120 have added more five percent or more to their population through domestic migration. Seven metropolitan areas have added more than 25 percent to their population through domestic migration, including Palm Coast, FL, The Villages, FL, St. George, UT, Cape Coral, FL, Bend, OR, Ocala, FL and Prescott, AZ.
Some of these patterns may change in the short run. For example, nearly one-third of the national increase in smaller regions has been in 16 Florida metropolitan areas, which have added 700,000 domestic migrants. These areas, with only one-quarter of the Florida’s 2000 population, accounted for almost 55 percent of the state’s domestic migration gain. The latest year’s domestic migration data indicates a declining rate of increase in Florida, probably due to its over priced housing and newly higher insurance costs.
On the other side, expect more from North Carolina, which enjoys a relatively strong economy and stable housing prices. Over the past seven years, North Carolina’s medium sized metropolitan areas gained the second largest number of domestic migrants, at 150,000. These eight areas accounted for 15 percent of the state’s population in 2000, yet captured 30 percent of the domestic migration gain.
Idaho placed third, gaining 107,000 domestic migrants, as people continued moving from coastal states inland. There’s no reason to expect this trend to slow significantly. Other states rounding out the top ten were South Carolina, Arizona, Washington, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Arkansas and Alabama.
Pennsylvania and Arkansas are the big surprises. Pennsylvania is the big domestic migration success story of the 2000s. The state has lost only 44,000 domestic migrants at the same time that its neighbors have lost more than 2,000,000. Pennsylvania’s mid-sized metropolitan areas have gained 65,000 domestic migrants, many of whom were fleeing the over-heated housing markets in the adjacent New York City and Washington-Baltimore areas. Arkansas reflects, at least partially, the Wal-Mart effect, with more than 50,000 domestic migrants moving to Fayetteville, which includes Bentonville and the headquarters of the world’s largest retailer.
The same trend towards smaller metropolitan areas can be seen in other states. In Utah, the medium sized metropolitan areas (Provo and St. George) have accounted for more than 160 percent of the state’s net domestic migration. In Oregon, nearly one-half of the domestic migration has been in five medium sized metropolitan areas with less than 15 percent of the state’s population in 2000. In Missouri, more than 125 percent of the domestic migration has been to three medium sized metropolitan areas, with the largest gain in Springfield.
The same pattern can be seen even in highly urbanized states. Maryland is losing domestic migrants overall, but the exurban metropolitan areas of Hagerstown, Salisbury and Lexington park managed to add more than 50,000. Another exurban success has been Colorado, where four metropolitan areas with 16 percent of the 2000 population accounted for more than 60 percent of the states domestic migration, led by Fort Collins and Greeley.
Finally, it is notable that Sioux Falls, SD and Bismarck, ND are among the medium sized metropolitan areas that are attracting so many domestic migrants. It is obvious that things are changing when more people are moving to Bismarck or Sioux Falls than to San Francisco, Los Angeles, Boston or Washington.
What does all this say? Clearly, the shape of America’s demography has been shifting, with a strong movement toward smaller metropolitan areas. Generally, these areas are newer, with little in the way of a traditional urban core. Many are wholly suburban. Indeed, the decentralization of the United States appears to be accelerating — from moving to the suburbs of large metropolitan areas to moving away from large metropolitan areas altogether.
There are good reasons for this to be so, from overly costly housing, to overly stressful traffic congestion to telecommunications advances. Some argue that high gas prices and the mortgage melt-down will now reverse this trend. Although the housing slowdown likely will slow out-migration down, it is unlikely to reverse the longer-term pattern. And as for high gas prices, the 1970s energy crisis did not result in a ‘back to the city’ movement, but actually quite the opposite. And in the 1970s, we did not have the Internet, which now allows people in smaller communities access to information once limited to those living in large metropolitan areas.
References:
Demographia Metropolitan Population & Migration 2000-2007
Comments
35 responses to “Sprawl Beyond Sprawl: America Moves to Smaller Metropolitan Areas”
Pennsylvania is the big domestic migration success story of the 2000s. The state has lost only 44,000 domestic migrants at the same time that its neighbors have lost more than 2,000,000. Pennsylvania’s mid-sized metropolitan areas have gained 65,000 domestic migrants, many of whom were fleeing the over-heated housing markets in the adjacent New York City and Washington-Baltimore areas. vps windows
Pennsylvania is the big domestic migration success story of the 2000s. The state has lost only 44,000 domestic migrants at the same time that its neighbors have lost more than 2,000,000. Pennsylvania’s mid-sized metropolitan areas have gained 65,000 domestic migrants, many of whom were fleeing the over-heated housing markets in the adjacent New York City and Washington-Baltimore areas. vps windows
What does all this say? Clearly, the shape of America’s demography has been shifting, with a strong movement toward smaller metropolitan areas. Generally, these areas are newer, with little in the way of a traditional urban core. Many are wholly suburban. Indeed, the decentralization of the United States appears to be accelerating — from moving to the suburbs of large metropolitan areas to moving away from large metropolitan areas altogether Bauchübungen
I really love reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Restposten Unlike additional blogs,I have read which are really not good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he enjoyed it as well Sonderposten
Domestic migrants are also important because they generally arrive at their new residences with more Epson EH-TW6000W resources than the average immigrant or newborn.
Domestic migrants are also important because they generally arrive at their new residences with more dedicated server resources than the average immigrant or newborn.
household relocation, which exclude worldwide immigration and the accepted augment of births in overload of death, tells us much about how citizens are ballot vote with their foot sweet love messages
I should acquaint you’ve aggressive me by this article. I’m absolutely absorbed by about one added superb article. I admire your internet armpit absolutely appreciably and acknowledge you for alive males and girls up with every one of the cast fresh attempt you are inventing.
chnlove review
What does all this say? Clearly, the shape of America’s demography has been shifting, with a strong movement toward smaller metropolitan areas. Generally, these areas are newer, with little in the way of a traditional urban core. Many are wholly suburban. ppi
In Oregon, nearly one-half of the domestic migration has been in five medium sized metropolitan areas with less than 15 percent of the state’s population in 2000. Nepali Movie List
I am satisfied to locate numerous useful information here in the post. Loft conversions London
I cant stand seeing people racially vilified. In this case his words offend me. visit this site
I’m going to bookmark this article for later. I think the next budget might have room for us to consider doing this. Wish it wasn’t a year from now… Roof Restorations
retailing of other things? Well, I love it. Principally the way that a really good shop can make you feel like you could move in and never ever leave. Mulberry Alexa Bags
Through a series of buy-outs, the original Schlitz formula was lost. house
This article is really useful and have been looking for some information on this topic. Great job and waiting for your next update. Grosshandel Sonderposten You are great with words. I’m sure you worked really hard on this article, and it shows. I agree with a lot of your material. I enjoyed this and I will be back for more.Good steps have been used in this article. By giving these type of examples we can easily understand what the writter is saying in this article. Grosshandel Adressen
Pennsylvania and Arkansas are the big surprises. Pennsylvania is the big domestic migration success story of the 2000s. The state has lost only 44,000 domestic migrants at the same time that its neighbors have lost more than 2,000,000. Pennsylvania’s mid-sized metropolitan areas have gained 65,000 domestic migrants, many of whom were fleeing the over-heated housing markets in the adjacent New York City and Washington-Baltimore areas. Arkansas reflects, at least partially, the Wal-Mart effect, with more than 50,000 domestic migrants moving to Fayetteville, which includes Bentonville and the headquarters of the world’s largest retailer. Webmaster of Acai Beeren
These eight areas accounted for 15 percent of the state’s population in 2000, yet captured 30 percent of the domestic migration gain. Electronica Music
It is obvious that things are changing when more people are moving to Bismarck or Sioux Falls than to San Francisco, Los Angeles, Boston or Washington. text spy
I’m satisfied to locate numerous useful information here in the post. redtube
It’s a good stage! hosting
Pennsylvania and Arkansas are the big surprises. Pennsylvania is the big domestic migration success story of the 2000s. The state has lost only 44,000 domestic migrants at the same time that its neighbors have lost more than 2,000,000. Pennsylvania’s mid-sized metropolitan areas have gained 65,000 domestic migrants, many of whom were fleeing the over-heated housing markets in the adjacent New York City and Washington-Baltimore areas. Arkansas reflects, at least partially, the Wal-Mart effect, with more than 50,000 domestic migrants moving to Fayetteville, which includes Bentonville and the headquarters of the world’s largest retailer. Simons Blog
I think this is a wonderful news for everyone “Finally, it is notable that Sioux Falls, SD and Bismarck, ND are among the medium sized metropolitan areas that are attracting so many domestic migrants. It is obvious that things are changing when more people are moving to Bismarck or Sioux Falls than to San Francisco, Los Angeles, Boston or Washington” I would definitely share this news with my friends
http://beingapharmacytechnician.com
The birthrate increase every year, it’s make the world getting crowded. Especially America look like getting smaller. endreamhost
It is not easy to provide true facts of any issue in this busy age. So you are really deserved to be appreciated.
techiestate
Good Post…. Manabadi Results
I found good information here
bankruptcy
website clone
smartphone review
It is obvious that things are changing when more people are moving to Bismarck or Sioux Falls than to San Francisco, Los Angeles, Boston or Washington. free cell phone spy
Its great At some point in your life time, you might have obtained a second mortgage for a home improvement or established a line of credit to pay off credit card bills, borrow for a college education, etc. So think of a reverse mortgage loan as a line of credit without any monthly payment. The line of credit (reverse mortgage) is repaid once the home is sold, or voluntarily paid back at your option. Interest accrues on the money you take from the line of credit. The bank advances you the equity on your house. The sum of money you will receive is based mainly on your age as well as the value of your home.
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/reverse-mortgage-loan/
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/hud-reverse-mortgage/
Many core cities continue to stagnate or even shrink, but their regions remain vibrant, expressing a form of urbanism that, while often unappreciated, remains vital and expansive. logiciel winamax
Great write-up, I am a big believer in commenting on blogs to assist the weblog writers know that they’ve added one thing worthwhile to the world large net!Anyway, in my language, there aren’t a lot good source like this. crystal ipad case
Spirulina is packed full of protein, and essential vitamins and minerals
that are needed by the body for optimal health and performance. If you
have a diet lacking the various Spirulina ingredients, you will notice
an increase in energy and general well being. ציון פסיכומטרי
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own BlogEngine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.wynajem samochodów wroclaw
You can write about the tips on the blog. You might relinquish it’s fascinating. Your blog recommendations may thicken your commissions.
buy youtube views
share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer hardwood flooring