America has become an overwhelmingly metropolitan nation. According to the 2000 census, more than 80 percent of the nation’s population resided in one of the 350 combined metropolitan statistical areas. It is not surprising, therefore, that “small town” America may be considered as becoming a burdensome anachronism.
Nothing could be further from the truth. America is more “small town” than we often think, particularly in how we govern ourselves. In 2000, slightly more than one-half of the nation’s population lived in jurisdictions — cities, towns, boroughs, villages and townships — with fewer than 25,000 people or in rural areas. Planners and geographers might see regions as mega-units, but in fact, they are usually composed of many small towns and a far smaller number of larger cities. Indeed, among the metropolitan areas with more than one million residents in 2000, the average sized city, town, borough, village or township had a population of little more than 20,000.
Although local government consolidation and regional governance is all the rage in policy circles, most Americans seem content with a diverse, even fractured governmental structure. According to the 2002 U.S. Census of Governments, there were more than 34,000 local general-purpose governments with less than 25,000 residents and 31,000 local general-purpose governments with less than 10,000 residents (accounting, with rural areas, for 38 percent of the nation’s 2000 population). With so many “small towns,” the average local jurisdiction population in the United States is 6,200.
Even in big metropolitan areas, citizens are often governed by small local institutions. People in Brecksville, Ohio (population 13,000), may tell their friends from far away that they live in Cleveland and residents of Woodway, Wash. (population 1,000), may claim to live in Seattle. But in reality their local governments are located not in the great City Hall downtown but in a usually quite modest nearby building.
This large number of governments horrifies some organizations and people. Planners, the media and many often well-meaning local activists argue that local governments should be consolidated to eliminate waste and duplication. And so, in recent years there have been strong initiatives to force local government consolidations. Bigger, the argument goes, is usually better and more efficient — and certainly easier to cover if you are a journalist and influence if you are a big business interest.
Yet the reality is that the claims of greater efficiency rarely confirm the theory. Both
Pennsylvania and New York recently started initiatives to consolidate their governmental structure. They took to heart the usual mantra that there are thousands of governments in the state and that they must be consolidated to save money. In both states, the efforts were clothed in promises that local government consolidation would improve competitiveness relative to other states.
However, the proponents never bothered to look at the data.
We did and the results were stunning. In both states, an equivalent “market basket” of spending was compared. In Pennsylvania, the largest local jurisdictions spent (including a per capita allocation of county expenditures, so that Philadelphia could be included. Social service spending was excluded) 150 percent more per capita than jurisdictions with between 5,000 and 10,000 population. The largest jurisdictions — those over 250,000 people — spent 200 percent more than jurisdictions with under 2,500 residents.
Moreover, it is not a matter of urban versus rural. In both the Philadelphia and Pittsburgh areas, there are literally hundreds of suburban jurisdictions that spent at less than one-half the per capita rate of the central cities.
The story was little different in New York. The largest jurisdictions (those over 100,000) spent nearly double per capita as jurisdictions with between 5,000 and 10,000 population (this would have been even greater if it had been possible to include New York City). The big governments spent even more (more than 150 percent) compared to jurisdictions with between 1,000 and 2,500 population. The differences were even greater within metropolitan areas, where smaller jurisdictions were even more efficient relative to the largest jurisdictions.
Why should this be? Perhaps it’s the old, all too often neglected Jeffersonian principle of downscaling government closer to the people. Elected officials who know more of their constituents are likely to be more responsive to their needs. Too often the principal economies of scale that occur from municipal consolidations are economies of scale for lobbyists and special interests.
Further, this small town governance structure is not limited to the United States. Metropolitan Paris has approximately 1,300 general-purpose local jurisdictions, more than any U.S. metropolitan area. Milan has more than 600. By comparison, Tokyo-Yokohama, the world’s largest metropolitan area, is a model of government consolidation, with more than 200 general-purpose governments.
America’s small town government structure engenders a sense of community, even as a part of larger metropolitan areas. They also save a lot of money, principally because democracy tends to work better when government is closer to home. It is not surprising that so many consolidation proposals fail and that when given the chance, voters usually reject consolidation proposals.
America needs both its small towns and its bigger cities. But make no mistake about it, even much of what we call a “metropolis” functions more effectively as a network of small towns.
The view of Main Street, Bramwell, West Virginia was photographed by Sandy Sorlien as part of her twenty-year project, The Heart of Town: Main Streets in America.
New Geography apologizes for having initially published the image without permission or attribution.
Resources:
Report for the Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors
Report for the Association of Towns of the State of New York
General-purpose governments by metropolitan area (2002)
Wendell Cox is a Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris and the author of “War on the Dream: How Anti-Sprawl Policy Threatens the Quality of Life.”
Comments
32 responses to “America is More Small Town than We Think”
And worse. With misplaced consolidation you get people on one side of the metropolis voting on how people on the other half of the metropolis should live; even when one sides preferences have really nothing to do with the others. Certainly democracy can work better when its appropriately decentralized – to resist those perverse effects.
Nothing could be further from the truth. America is more “small town” than we often think, particularly in how we govern ourselves. In 2000, slightly more than one-half of the nation’s population lived in
locksmith
locksmith service
This is very nice thought and concept. Thanks
Coursework
yes right it is a small town but the population is increasing day by day… http://www.tajweddingservices.co.uk/mehendi_services.html
Great job here. I really enjoyed what you had to say. Keep going because you definitely bring a new voice to this subject. Not many people would say what you’ve said and still make it interesting. Well, at least I’m interested.
Cell phone spy
cell phone spy software
But that doesn’t mean you have to write a whole article about it. The level of quality is just below what I usually read, that’s for sure Artikel Lesen yeah
The trend of leaving in villages or rural arrears of America is decreasing day by because people of US likes metropolitan life style more. I recently buy coursework on that topic
uk website Find Out How You Can Become Debt Free: Free Information on What to Do and Where to Get Help. Debt Solutions to Solve Your Debt Problems: Find Out What Debt Options and Help are Available to You. Tips to Become Debt Free: Find Out How You Can Become Debt Free and Get Your Finances Back on Track. Free Debt Help, Advice and Support: A Helping Hand To Get You On Your Way To A Debt Free Lifestyle
text your ex back michael fiore Text Your Ex Back Michael Fiore PDF reviews, Text Your Ex Back official website. A collection of top posts and videos about the Michael Fiore Text Your Ex Back 2.0 system. Includes PDF reviews, download information, and texting tips and examples.
get rid of herpes sarah wilcox Get Rid Of Herpes Ebook: Herpes Home Remedies To Eliminate Herpes Simplex Type 2 Outbreaks And Keep Them From Ever Coming Back. This site is a leading resource for information about the Sarah Wilcox Get Rid Of Herpes PDF book and herpes treatment system that teaches you how to eliminate herpes outbreaks step-by-step using a simple, natural, and permanent method from home.
how to jump higher Freak Jump Technique 3 Ebook: A Jump Higher Workout For Improving Your Vertical As Soon As Today…No Weights Required. This site is a leading resource for information about the Adam Linkenauger Freak Jump Technique 3 PDF book, videos, and complete vertical leap training program that teaches you how to increase your vertical using step-by-step jumping workouts designed to provide insane results fast!
America may be considered as becoming a burdensome anachronism. example sympathy message
http://rebelmouse.com The Amber Starr Pole Dancing Course: Fun, Engaging, Step-By-Step And Easy To Follow Video Instructions To Learn How To Pole Dance From Home. It’s Fun And Fit Exotic Dancing For Everyday Women. This site is a leading resource for information about the Amber Starr PDF book and video training system that teaches online pole dancing classes and pole fitness for beginners and seasoned dancers alike.
But make no mistake about it, even much of what we call a “metropolis” functions more effectively as a network of small towns. sora class nj
download the pdf All-Belly Pregnancy Program: How To Eat And Exercise When Expecting To Stay Fit, Have A Strong, Healthy Baby, And Be One “Hot Mama”! This site is a leading resource for information about the Ryan Watson and Flavia Del Monte All Belly Pregnancy PDF book, diet manual, and exercises for pregnant women that help you carry your pregnancy weight with ease, prepare you for giving birth and beyond, and help you keep your baby healthy and happy inside the womb.
capture his heart 3 steps Capture His Heart Ebook: How To Make Your Man Fall Deeply And Passionately In Love So He Never Wants To Leave. This site is a leading resource for information about the Claire Casey Capture His Heart PDF book and lasting commitment program that teaches you how to “flip the switch” in a man’s mind that makes him fall madly in love, give you his total commitment, and see you as the only woman in the world.
http://www.riftgold.net/ Welcome to riftgold.net : Rift gold Instant Delivery is ready for you! Lowest Price and 100% Safe Delivery,7/24/365 live Support Service.
Nothing could be further from the truth. America is more “small town” than we often think, particularly in how we govern ourselves. photo booth rentals in nj
But in reality their local governments are located not in the great City Hall downtown but in a usually quite modest nearby building. buy facebook likes
It is not surprising, therefore, that “small town” America may be considered as becoming a burdensome anachronism. aflnc.com
@geekmiss We tend to neglect the presence of “small towns” and how it helps in the growth of the state. I would say more than urban, suburban contribute to the jurisdictions. The data recorded between New York, Philadelphia, Pittsburg, were actually to be looked upon and helps in understanding the population statistics.Worth read I must agree.
website Sea Horizon EC will be accessible via Pasir Ris MRT Station. Commuting to Changi Airport as well as Expo is therefore very convenient. It is also near to White Sands and Pasir Park. For vehicle owners, it takes less than 15 minutes to drive to Changi Business Hub and the vibrant Expo Area, via Tampines Expressway (TPE) and Pan Island Expressway (PIE)…
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can’t wait to read lots of your posts.
http://songbai.co
Bigger, the argument goes, is usually better and more efficient — and certainly easier to cover if you are a journalist and influence if you are a big business interest. http://www.everycode.co.uk/store/bhs/
This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it
Welcome to Ecolar Panel
I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people.
Liquor Magazine
I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work.
Medical Assistant Training – Salary, Jobs, Certification & Schools
Indeed, among the metropolitan areas with more than one million residents in 2000, the average sized city, town, borough, village or township had a population of little more plumber clifton nj
Great article with excellent idea!Thank you for such a valuable article. I really appreciate for this great information..
the harmony band lebanon
A outstanding internet promotion technique with a outstanding catchphrase could create you buy a item, even if the top quality it`s not very outstanding. buy quality backlink
pr5 backlink
high Pagerank Backlinks
I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
Manual Directory Submission
Buy backlinks
high pagerank backlinks
I am glad this it turned out so well and I hope it will continue in the future because it is so interesting and meaningful to the community. hillford singapore