For the past decade a large coterie of pundits, prognosticators and their media camp followers have insisted that growth in America would be concentrated in places hip and cool, largely the bluish regions of the country.
Since the onset of the recession, which has hit many once-thriving Sun Belt hot spots, this chorus has grown bolder. The Wall Street Journal, for example, recently identified the “Next Youth-Magnet Cities” as drawn from the old “hip and cool” collection of yore: Seattle, Portland, Washington, New York and Austin, Texas.
It’s not just the young who will flock to the blue meccas, but money and business as well, according to the narrative. The future, the Atlantic assured its readers, did not belong to the rubes in the suburbs or Sun Belt, but to high-density, high-end places like New York, San Francisco and Boston.
This narrative, which has not changed much over the past decade, is misleading and largely misstated. Net migration, both before and after the Great Recession, according to analysis by the Praxis Strategy Group, has continued to be strongest to the predominately red states of the South and Intermountain West.
This seems true even for those seeking high-end jobs. Between 2006 and 2008, the metropolitan areas that enjoyed the fastest percentage shift toward educated and professional workers and industries included nominally “unhip” places like Indianapolis, Charlotte, N.C., Memphis, Tenn., Salt Lake City, Jacksonville, Fla., Tampa, Fla., and Kansas City, Mo.
The overall migration numbers are even more revealing. As was the case for much of the past decade, the biggest gainers continue to include cities such as San Antonio, Dallas and Houston. Rather than being oases for migrants, some oft-cited magnets such as New York, Boston, Los Angeles and Chicago have all suffered considerable loss of population to other regions over the past year.
Much the same pattern emerges when you look at longer-term state demographic patterns. A recent survey by the Empire Center for New York State Policy found that the biggest net losers in terms of per capita outmigration between 2000 and 2008 were, with the exception of Louisiana, all blue state bastions. New York residents lead in terms of rate of exodus, closely followed by the District of Columbia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and California.
An even greater shock to the sensibilities of the insular, Manhattan-centric media, the report found that most of the movement from the Empire State was not from the much-dissed suburbia, but from that hip and cool paragon, New York City. This can not be ascribed as a loss of the unwanted: According to the report, those leaving the city had 13% higher incomes than those coming in.
How can this be, when everyone who’s smart and hip is headed to the Big Apple? This question was addressed in a report by the center-left, New York-based Center for an Urban Future. True, considerable numbers of young, educated people come to New York, but it turns out that many of them leave for the suburbs or other states as they reach their peak earning years.
Indeed, it’s astonishing given the many clear improvements in New York that more residents left the five boroughs for other locales in 2006, the peak of the last boom, than in 1993, when the city was in demonstrably worse shape. In 2006, the city had a net loss of 153,828 residents through domestic out-migration, compared to a decline of 141,047 in 1993, with every borough except Brooklyn experiencing a higher number of out-migrants in 2006.
Of course, blue state boosters can point out that the exodus has slowed with the recession, as opportunities have dried up elsewhere. True, the flood of migration has slowed across the nation. Yet it has only slowed, not dried up. When the economy revives, it’s likely to start flowing heavily again.
More important, the key group leaving New York and other so-called “youth-magnets” comprises the middle class, particularly families, critical to any long-term urban revival. This year’s Census shows that the number of single households in New York has reached record levels; in Manhattan, more than half of all households are singles. And the Urban Future report’s analysis found that even well-heeled Manhattanites with children tend to leave once they reach the age of 5 or above.
The key factor here may well be economic opportunity. Virtually all the supposedly top-ranked cities cited in this media narrative have suffered below-average job growth throughout the decade. Some, like Portland and New York, have added almost no new jobs; others like San Francisco, Boston and Chicago have actually lost positions over the past decade.
In contrast, even after the current doldrums, San Antonio, Orlando, Houston, Dallas and Phoenix all boast at least 5% more jobs now than a decade ago. Among the large-narrative magnet regions only one–government-bloated greater Washington–has enjoyed strong employment growth.
The impact of job growth on the middle class has been profound. New York City, for example, has the smallest share of middle-income families in the nation, according to a recent Brookings Institution study; its proportion of middle-income neighborhoods was smaller than that of any metropolitan area except Los Angeles.The same pattern has also emerged in what has become widely touted as America’s “model city”–President Obama’s adopted hometown of Chicago.
The likely reasons behind these troubling trends are things rarely discussed in “the narrative”–concerns like high costs, taxes and regulations making it tough on industries that employ the middle class. One clear culprit: out of control state spending. State spending in New York is second per capita in the nation (anomalous Alaska is first); California stands fourth and New Jersey seventh. Illinois is down the list but coming up fast. Over the past decade, while its population grew by only 7%, Illinois’ spending grew by an inflation-adjusted 39%.
The problem here is more than just too-large government; it lies in how states spend their money. Massive public spending increases over the past decade in California, New Jersey, Illinois and New York have gone overwhelmingly into the pockets and pensions of public employees. It certainly has not flowed into such basic infrastructure as roads, bridges and ports that are needed to keep key industries competitive.
The American Association of State Highway Transportation, for example, ranked New York 43rd in the country and New Jersey dead last in terms of quality of roads. Some 46% of the Garden State’s roads were rated in poor condition, compared with the national average of 13%, even as the state’s spending reached new highs. The typical New Jersey driver spends almost $600 a year in auto repairs necessitated by the poor conditions of the roads.
In contrast, states in the South and parts of the Plains tend to pour their public resources into productive uses. Cities like Mobile, Ala., Houston, Charleston, S.C., and Savannah, Ga., have been investing in port facilities to take advantage of the planned widening of the Panama Canal. The primary goal is to take business away from the increasingly expensive, overregulated and under-invested ports of the Northeast and West Coast. Similarly, places like Kansas City and the Dakotas are looking to boost their basic rail and road networks to support export-heavy industries.
Even in the face of the Obama administration’s strongly urban-centric, blue state-oriented economic policy, these generally less than hip places appear poised to grow as the economy recovers. Virtually all the top 10 economies that have withstood the recession come from outside the “youth-magnet” field: San Antonio; Oklahoma City; Little Rock, Ark.; Dallas, Baton Rouge, La.; Tulsa, Okla., Omaha, Neb.; Houston and El Paso, Texas. The one exception to this rule, Austin, also benefits from being located in solvent, generally low-tax Texas.
This continued erosion of jobs and the middle class from the blue states and cities is not inevitable. Many of these places enjoy enormous assets in terms of universities, strategic location, concentrations of talented workers and entrenched high-wage industries. But short of a massive and continuing bailout from Washington, the only way to reverse their decline will be a thorough reformation of their governmental structure and policies. No narrative, no matter how well spun, can make up for that reality.
This article originally appeared at Forbes.com.
Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and is a distinguished presidential fellow in urban futures at Chapman University. He is author of The City: A Global History
Comments
77 responses to “Numbers Don’t Support Migration Exodus to “Cool Cities””
Is there some way to plot these figures against cities that have implemented Smart Growth policies over the same time periods?
Wendell has done it for housing affordability and it could be interesting to plot Smart Growth against Migration and Employment Growth.
Owen McShane, Kaiwaka, New Zealand.
Director, Centre for Resource Management Studies.
http://www.rmastudies.org.nz/
While it is clear that many “hip and cool” cities have seen declines in population and employment, I don’t quite understand how a low overall employment ranking or negative migration figures make these places undesirable.
Perhaps those places are finding the balance between growth rates and maintaining quality of life. If a city is transitioning and as a result the old-world jobs and employees migrate to the suburbs or exurbs, is that necessarily a bad thing?
|Campinas Acompanhantes em Campinas
|Dentista BH Belo Horizonte BH Belo Horizonte
|Acompanhantes Salvador Acompanhantes em Salvador
You must know by now, your post goes to the nitty-gritty of the patient matter. Your quality basically leaves me seeking to know more. Just so you know, i will instantly pick up your feast to keep up currently with your on the internet site. Looking Out thanks is basically my little way of saying excellent job for a amazing source. Take my best needs for your next publish. spy on text messages
desemtupimentorecrutamento e selecao bh como recrutar treinamentos rh
Database Normalization
Great post, Your article shows tells me you must have a lot of background in this topic. Can you direct me to other articles about this? I will recommend this article to my friends as well. Keep it up.
I’ve desired to post about something similar to this on one of my blogs and this has given me an idea. I’ve really found out a great deal studying this site. Plainly especially excellent content herelaw school personal statement
|desemtupir entupiu Desentupidora em BH
|plastica em bh Cirurgia Plastica BH
|Cogumelo Cogumelo Agaricus
|oleo argan
recrutando bem coaching bh consuntar planos de cargos e salarios planos de salarios cursos de lideranca bh otimo site acompanhantes bh gostei bastante tambem acompanhantes bh
I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick..SEO Los Angeles
Nice discussion here,you are doing a great job. i was looking for this information. i found it on your page it’s really amazing. I like that information. I am sure that these are your own views. They are really awsome. You are really fantastic. thanks
~Vicente R. Granville, Miami car accident attorney
I also love the information being shared here! Let’s just get back here from time to time and maybe, find some new updates! have a nice day!
Matthew Lee
This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog. Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick… clubmz reviews
This is a topic of my interest. I love reading through your blog, I wanted to leave a little comment to support you and wish you a good continuation. Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts.
purchasing steel tubes
Thanks for the post.Your knowledge of the subject is very deep.Took me a while to read all the comments but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!
cell phone spy
Thanks for the post.Your knowledge of the subject is very deep.Took me a while to read all the comments but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!
zwemvijvers
Great post, Your article shows tells me you must have a lot of background in this topic. Can you direct me to other articles about this? I will recommend this article to my friends as well. Keep it up.
العاب بنات
This narrative, which has not changed much over the past decade, is misleading and largely misstated. Net migration, both before and after the Great Recession, according to analysis by the Praxis Strategy Group, has continued to be strongest to the predominately red states of the South and Intermountain West.transport
Washington, the only way to reverse their decline will be a thorough reformation of their governmental structure and policies. No narrative, no matter how well spun, can make up for that reality Photoshop Training
I haven’t any word to appreciate this post…..Really i am impressed from this post….the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.
caboolture bathroom renovation
I share the same point of view. This is a very good article with deep vision inside the matter
—————
Myanmar tours
Wow what a Great Information about World Day its very nice informative post. thanks for the post.
http://www.parier.ch/
Great post, Your article shows tells me you must have a lot of background in this topic. Can you direct me to other articles about this? I will recommend this article to my friends as well. Keep it up. Wunderbeere
It is nice that you posted something like this and I am quite lucky to read it. Thanks for posting this! movado
|Mudanças em SP Mudanças
|Guarda Volumes Guarda Moveis SP
|nutricionistas Nutricionista BH
|Lagoa caixa d’água bh
Your post explains the current trend of migration in young Americans; most of the young Americans are migrating to places like Seattle, Portland and Washington. The business also will migrate to this place. Your post is really helpful for investors to invest more in these areas.microsoft support team
|Outsourcing Copy Green
|Empresa de mudancas Guarda Moveis e guarda moveis
|Empresa de mudancas Guarda Volumes e guarda moveis
|Empresa de mudancas Guarda Documentos e guarda moveis
The nice blog having nice information. some times we ignore this sort of things & also suffer a lot as well. hoodia
helo you have a nice blog.
Please visit our website about empresas de mudanças
For other locations visit our locations.
mudanças sp
mudanças rj
mudanças belo horizonte
Good to know, and i agree, the one`s that are falling, have to change their polices and strategies in order to get up again.
Anyways.
Perdendo barriga
B. Regards,
Matheus
This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. fitflop
The best answer may have hidden elements but I would like to say that writer has creative memory of knowledge , if you think and like my suggestion then you may has a look over personal finance tips
I have been checking out a few of your articles and Nice post, good to know that this Library topic is being covered also in this web site.
Thanks for taking time to discuss this, keep up with this interesting work.
Good job ! – Electrolizer
I have written things I would love to take back, goo work, keep it up. Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. – deck drain
helo you have a nice blog.
Please visit our website about empresas de
redes de proteção
For other locations visit our locations.
redes de proteção rj
redes rj
redes de proteção
Thane has become the largest district in the Mumbai larger metropolitan area, with a population of 11.1 million, passing Outer Mumbai. Thane is now the largest district in India. In 2001 Thane had 8.1 million residents in 2001 and grew 35 percent to 2011. This, however, is down from a 55 percentfree business advertising
Great article, Graham. Good grief. I can see the frustration over opt in messages on every page begin. Be interesting to see what this looks like played out. Let the popups begin. Travel To Vietnam
New Jersey dead last in terms of quality of roads. Some 46% of the Garden State’s roads were rated in poor condition, compared with the national average of 13%, even as the state’s spending reached new highs.text your ex back examples
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles.
http://glos.si
Report has shown that 50% of small business don’t market their business for potential costumer and that is why people don’t know about their products and services. So how can they do a good business that is a question which need to be answered. http://www.erectz.com
Great post. I totally agree, that the key factor here may well be economic opportunity.
Fatburner Traning
The primary goal is to take business away from the increasingly expensive, overregulated and under-invested ports of the Northeast and West Coast. Similarly, places like Kansas City and the Dakotas are looking to boost their basic rail and road networks to support export-heavy industries.dreambox
The one exception to this rule, Austin, also benefits from being located in solvent, generally low-tax Texas.joomla web hosting
The primary goal is to take business away from the increasingly expensive, overregulated and under-invested ports of the Northeast and West Coast. model trains
That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article Riordain
searchengineoptimizationpackages
searchengineoptimizationpricing
thelinkbuildingservices
buyhighprlinkseo
highprbacklinksseo
manualdirectorysubmission There are a lot of blogs and articles out there on this topic, but you have acquired another side of the subject. This is good content thank you for sharing it.
http://www.onewaylinkingservice.com
http://www.pagerankbacklinks.inBook of Ra connected has been planned decided on your favored diversion and methodologies with 5 reels and 9 pay-lines. A space machine is there and it has wild scramble in addition to hazard aspects that will permit entertainers illuminate and gathers past predeterminations of the Pharoah on top of their compartment. This makes the gambling joint sizzling sultry on the web.
http://www.socialbookmarkings.co
http://www.socialbookmarkingservices.biz
http://www.buy-back-links.com
http://www.gameswebdir.com
http://www.onewaylinkingservice.com
http://www.pagerankbacklinks.inBook of Ra connected has been planned decided on your favored diversion and methodologies with 5 reels and 9 pay-lines. A space machine is there and it has wild scramble in addition to hazard aspects that will permit entertainers illuminate and gathers past predeterminations of the Pharoah on top of their compartment. This makes the gambling joint sizzling sultry on the web.
http://www.socialbookmarkings.co
http://www.socialbookmarkingservices.biz
http://www.buy-back-links.com
http://www.gameswebdir.com
. We’re offering it on a donation basis, and ask each participant to contribute $5 – $10 to support this and other initiatives led by The Interdependence Project.
math homework help
Anne, best wishes from the telefonkatalogen.biz.
This is really a very good point you raised here.Here onward i would try to post some good quality comments on each blog i will visit.
artswebdirectory.com
autosmobiledirectory.com
bookswebdirectory.com
businesswebsdirectory.com
communicationswebdirectory.com
computerswebdirectory.com
Those are the wages of cynicism and thoughtless materialism.It is incumbent on the people themselves to wrest control of this machine from those who would modify it for ill.Only the governed can guarantee that the government works for good.
The primary goal is to take business away from the increasingly expensive, overregulated and under-invested ports of the Northeast and West Coast. Similarly, places like Kansas City and the Dakotas are looking to boost their basic rail and road networks to support export-heavy pen tool Photoshop
kids and teens articles Worse yet, however, many no longer see it as a tool at all, but rather as an entity unto itself, controlling them but uncontrollable.
This post and simply fantastic, shame that in Brazil Sao Paulo and Rio de Janeiro not have blogs with matter so vast and intelligent. Raposo Tavares – Rua João Guilherme 05528-240 9-6857-8705 http://www.tudocondominio.com.br
redes de proteção|
redes de proteção rj |
redes de proteção sp|
redes rj|
redes de proteção abc|
redes de proteção ipiranga|
redes de proteção mooca|
telas para quadras|
redes de proteção tatuape|
redes de proteção piscinas|
redes de proteção niteroi|
redes de proteção rio de janeiro|
redes de proteção guaruja|
redes de proteção santos|
redes de proteção bh|
Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, This info is very good for me. This is a great post. I like – this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.
asia leopard trolley in delhi
There’s no word to describe such a great masterpiece. You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject an enlightenment for us to gain knowledge and information without any arguments to deal with.
This link is very informative…
Hivelocity Review
LED lights are used all over the world for the different types of benefits . Led aquarium lighting is good looking and can be used in place These need to be decorated.
There are a lot of blogs and articles out there on this topic, but you have captured another side of the subject. This is reliable content thank you for sharing it. send flowers
Internet is very unique way to advertising and selling things,i am providing in los angeles online marketing services to many companies.
Derma Seta
I found this informative and interesting blog so i think so its very useful and knowledge able.I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
Yes, America may be suffering from unemployment right now. But with the prevalence of immigrants, I just hope that this will awaken most Americans and say to themselves that they need to act unless they want to see a lot of immigrants getting all what they also should deserve to get. Instead of immigrants working in offices and other places of work, it would be nice if the Americans themselves are the ones working. I just hope everyone will have a change of attitude. A positive attitude, that is.
Sarah Jones
They have provided strong quantitative evidence, based upon voluminous econometric analysis that cities tend to become more efficient as they grow in population. Welsh Rugby shirts
Thanks for such an interesting article here. I was searching for something like that for quite a long time and at last I have found it here.high PR backlinks
This is simple equation, to tell you the truth. The primary goal here, actually, is to take business away from the increasingly expensive, overregulated and under-invested ports of the Northeast and West Coast.
John Tyrone Williams
I really love reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs,I have read which are really not good.
Houston fence company
Very good blog great articles. But I do not agree with all the information. But the blog is worth a look. small business web design
It can’t be denied that the number of people migrating to the U.S. is increasing. However, other countries also have seen a lot of people migrating to their countries like Australia, Canada, New Zealand, etc.
Thomas Peart
Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written.will be referring a lot of friends about this. Keep blogging.
fences pasadena tx
It’s smart, well-written and easy to understand. You have my attention on this subject. I will be back.FRP Grating Junction Box Transmitter Enclosure
Whether we like it or not, recession is hovering above us right now. Unless we do something about it, it will surely rain like cats & dogs!
Laura Hunter
To become an online marketer after 15 hours with Virtual Staff Finder Academy. It has 5 useful modules
Its really a very interesting posting indeed. Thanks for sharing such interesting posting with us.
tutun
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks!
SEO packages
This is one of the best blog because, there are lot of informative postings.
Buy backlinks
high Pagerank Backlinks
This blog will be a great source blog for those who wants to know about this topic. You have provided us with many essential articles that definitely put a new spin on a subject
Manual Directory Submission manual social bookmarking
I just came across your home butcher supplies blog and reading your beautiful words. I thought I would leave my first comment but I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.