Every now and then, some East Coast based publication sends a reporter out to California to see how the West Coast’s economy is doing. I think they write these things sitting at a restaurant patio overlooking the Pacific Ocean. That can be seductive, and lulled into a comfortable sense that all is well with the world, the reporter always gets it wrong.
The most recent example is this New York Times article. The second paragraph summarizes the article:
Communities all along the state’s coastline have largely bounced back from the recession, some even prospering with high-tech and export businesses growing and tourism coming back. At the same time, communities from just an hour’s drive inland and stretching all the way to the Nevada and Arizona borders struggle with stubbornly high unemployment and a persistent housing crisis. And the same pattern holds the length of the state, from Oregon to the Mexican frontier.
The next paragraph contains the mandatory quote from California’s favorite economic Pollyanna, Steve Levy:
“This is really a tale of two economies,” said Stephen Levy, the director of the Center for Continuing Study of the California Economy. “The coastal areas are either booming or at least doing well, and the areas that were devastated still have a long way to go. The places that existed just for housing are not going to come back anytime soon.”
The article is accompanied by a photo of a couple driving a red Ferrari convertible. The caption says "Driving through Newport Beach in Orange County. Communities along the coast have largely rebounded from the recession."
This is all nonsense.
There are two reasonable measures of recovery, jobs and real estate values. You can forget the real estate values measure. Values throughout California are down from pre-recession highs. They are down a lot. Only San Francisco and Marin counties, with median home prices down 27.7 percent and 32.3 percent, respectively, have seen net median home price declines of less than 40 percent. Monterey and Madera counties top the state in median home price declines, in excess of 67 percent.
So let’s use jobs. An area has recovered if it has as many jobs today as it had at the beginning of the recession, December 2008.
We monitor 37 California MSAs. Combined they represent about 96 percent of California’s population. By jobs, only one of California’s larger MSAs has recovered, and that county does not fit the story. Not only is Kings County not on the ocean, it doesn’t even border or have a naturally occurring year-round piece of water. Kings County, with 37,700 jobs, has about 900 more jobs than it had at the beginning of the recession. Still, Kings County’s unemployment rate is 17 percent. Some recovery!
Orange County, which the New York Times article cites as largely rebounded, is down 127,800 jobs from its pre-recession high. That’s an 8.5 percent decline. Los Angeles County is down 337,000 or 8.1 percent of jobs. The difference between unemployment rates, 8.0 percent in Orange County versus 12.1 percent in Los Angeles County, reflects different unemployment levels at the beginning of the recession and the high cost of living in Orange County. Most people can’t afford to be unemployed long in Orange County. You either find a job, or you leave.
Here are the Counties that have lost, on net, less than 6 percent of jobs in the recession:
County/MSA |
Job gain |
percent change |
Unemployment |
|
Imperial |
-100 |
-0.2% |
26.7% |
|
Kings |
900 |
2.4% |
17.0% |
|
Merced |
-2,800 |
-4.8% |
20.0% |
|
Monterey |
-5,600 |
-4.3% |
15.3% |
|
San Diego |
-66,400 |
-5.1% |
9.3% |
|
San Francisco |
-33,600 |
-3.4% |
8.0% |
|
Santa Clara |
-19,900 |
-2.1% |
8.8% |
|
San Luis Obispo |
-5,900 |
-5.7% |
8.7% |
|
Santa Barbara |
-8,200 |
-4.7% |
8.9% |
|
Santa Cruz |
-3,800 |
-4.1% |
13.6% |
|
Solano |
-6,100 |
-4.8% |
10.9% |
It’s hard to find real recovery here. Three of the sub-10-percent-unemployment-rate counties (Marin, San Luis Obispo, and Santa Barbara) are home to the wealthy, those who serve them, and a very small middle class. They have not had and will never have anything like robust economies. Think of them as big Leisure Villages for the terminally fashionable.
That leaves San Diego, San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara counties as potential vigorous economies. Let’s look at these regions’ job creation last month. Unfortunately, the data are only available by MSA. San Diego County saw job growth of 1,300 jobs in February, an increase of about 0.11 percent. Santa Clara/San Benito saw job growth of about 4,100, or 0.46 percent. San Francisco/San Mateo/Marin saw growth of about 7,100 jobs, or 0.74 percent.
It looks to me like there is a small island of relative prosperity: San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara Counties, but even these counties have not fully recovered. This island is indeed on the coast, but it represents just a small fraction of the coastal county population.
The idea that there is some sort of Coastal resurgence in California is just absurd. Certainly, the 593,800 still unemployed in Los Angeles — by far the state’s most populous — are not likely to agree that “The coastal areas are either booming or at least doing well…"
Bill Watkins is a professor at California Lutheran University and runs the Center for Economic Research and Forecasting, which can be found at clucerf.org.
California coast photo by BigStockPhoto.com.
Comments
42 responses to “California Recovery: No, It Is Not East vs. West”
Bill, can’t you get nonfarm employment data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics at the county level?
In Los Angeles, there are still homes that were worth 900K or more before the recession and are worth 300K now, something I noticed when looking at a job with STATS LLC there. The smaller cities along the coast (e.g. San Luis Obispo) had highly services-oriented economies that depend heavily on interior California agriculture, tourism and highway traffic, all three of which at varying levels of bad. The only place that seems to be doing okay is Silicon Valley, which is being held together partially by green energy subsidies from the Federal Government, and is also helped slightly by a cheap US Dollar enabling exports of high-tech goods. Many coastal areas have gone bankrupt, losing nearly all their city services including road maintenance and police.
In a lot of cases those unemployment numbers are actually sunnier then the reality because a lot of the people who lost their jobs left California, some for Mexico, some for other parts of the US, bringing down the unemployment rate on their way out the door.
You got a definitely helpful blog I’ve been right here reading for about an hour. I’m a newbie and your accomplishment is quite a lot an inspiration for me.
sandy
I like your blog post it contains great information now i want talk about seo Search engine optimization (seo)is the process of improving the visibility of website in search engines through the “seo tips”. In general, people want to know google analytics higher ranked on the search results page and more frequently a site appears in the search results, the more visitors it will get from the search engine users
Thank you very much for that extraordinarily first class editorial!
write my essay saudi-arabia
This is what actually I was looking for thanks a lot for making the platform where we can discuss our issues.
NBK Capital | Western Auto UN
Thanks a lot to share this my friend.
Esimsar
I do agree with the information provided as i have seen happening all this my self at many of the places. People are interested to cover those stories that could get them attentions on any of the subjects.
Regards,
accommodation in kharkov Ukraine
These are really some good figure regarding the subject. These figures could really help the authorities to get better future for the unemployed people.
Regards,
debt relief companies
You’ve got it, whatever that means in blogging. Anyway, You’re definitely someone that has something to say that people should hear. Keep up the wonderful job. Keep on inspiring the people!
shooter games
Thanks for publishing the interesting data, looks like San Diego is not fairing too well.
_______________________________________
http://tinyurl.com/pdfinance – Take out finance with the best online lender
I like your blog post it contains great information.home tutor
The Patagonia jackethas become one of the most recognized outdoor pieces of Patagonia coats among outdoor enthusiast around the world, and Men’s all waterproof shells are good reason. Women’s all waterproof shells is an incredibly versatile, packable and lightweight insulated jacket and definitely a shop favorite among the staff at Patagonia women jacket
http://www.patagoniajacket.net
That leaves San Diego, San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara counties as possibles vigorous economies. Let’s wait at these regions’ job commencement end month. Unluckily, the information are exclusive acquirable by MSA. http://www.testbells.com/642-427.html
Hey I really like this blog here and also want share a link of best real estate company of Saudi Arabia to my friends.
شركات العقار | شقق للبيع في الرياض | شقق للبيع الخبر
I really appreciate some helpful replies.
thank you . That is useful information. I will check to find my first letter I got from them.
So is this true even if there is a parent company involved ? That parent company will still try to find another contract but that could take time and I will not be making any money but technically i am still employed with the parent company. So does it count as a layoff ?
Vincentkinson
It is very difficult to find all information about Pakistan at one place and I have run exhaustive search but could find appropriate stuff, however this website provides very good information and should be shared with all those looking for Latest Information About Pakistan.
There is nothing more rewarding than working with an Aktion Club. My husband and i look forward to attending their meetings and going to the Aktion Club convention with them.
literature review of motivation
El orden del día de la reunión es acerca de las subvenciones para empresas en las que se estaba planeando por un tiempo muy largo.
fort worth personal injury attorney
My childhood was there at Houston, I used to lost there a lot of times there. “Inside the loop” was very familiar phrase to me.google-chart
Two real estate investment trusts with extensive holdings in Hampton Roads – First Potomac Realty Trust and Liberty Property Trust – scored positive in a report from SNL Real Estate, a business intelligence service based in Charlottesville.
http://ntxrealestategroup.com/
Hi dude, really like this concept. I did not know much more about California Recovery issue which you have allocated here but the discussion you have made here simply makes me knowable about this issue. Thanks dude.
http://www.eminent-construction.com/
The data is showing the real picture of the situation and as well as in all aspects. Pornogay
It is very difficult to find all information about Pakistan at one place and I have run exhaustive search but could find appropriate stuff.Langleyjames It recruitment
Just wanna thanks for sharing this blog. I’d like to share this one too –
E-commerce Holiday Spending: Forecast for 2012
The blog you’ve post was very interesting and informative. Thanks for sharing this one. I’d like to share this to you – Starting A Business is not an easy task. You have to learn first how to market your business.
I think their economy is now doing well. Very interesting article. I’d like to share this one too – multi-channel marketing. Know the secrets in establishing successful business.
I completely agree with you. I really like this article. It contains a lot of useful information. I can set up my new idea from this post. It gives in depth information. Thanks for this valuable information for all. And of course nice review about the application.
vakantiehuis dordogne
Thank you very much for the great list and I appreciate your efforts to bring such a huge list for us. I really appreciate posts, which might be of very useful. I look forward to future updates. Once again thanks. Keep smiling.
Get More Twitter Followers
But more often than not, she says, recyclers ship e-waste overseas to developing countries. Using no protective measures whatsoever, workers there then dismantle them for valuable copper wiring or other components they can sell for money. Children often do the salvaging, and in the process are exposed to metals and chemicals that can cause severe brain damage or developmental problems. Water Damage Seattle WA
Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear reason of issues. It contains truly facts. Your website is very beneficial. Thanks for sharing. Palos Verdes Estates Garage Door Repair Glad to visit your blog, I seem to be forward to more good articles and I think we all like to thank so many fine articles, blog to share with us.
I think you’ve made some truly interesting points. Not too many people would actually think about this the way you just did. I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject that have been uncovered and you did it so well, with so much class. Thanks
SEO
In fact, line-height values have long been the topic that dare not speak its name. I hope it is not too immodest of me to say that writing cv templates about these subjects took no small measure of personal courage.
I like that types of places. California is the beautiful province. Maybe Gov.t have to recovered these types of Places. Now, this website is give me Excellent information. I’ve study your own issues in advance.I adore what you have got here.
This post shows a report that is tighten to common. credible strategy of countenance resulting from which cause your post turn so informative. Some truly superb blog posts on this internet site, thanks for contribution.
Custom tote bags
So informative and interesting post have been shared here.It’s very nice website. I will search this page again & again great list. I appreciate your efforts to bring such a huge list for us. Thanks a lot for sharing.
sell a business
I had fun reading this post. Very informative as well. I didn’t know the procedure can be easy. your blog is very nice.Thanks for posting this important blog on your website. I appreciate your efforts to bring such a huge list for us. Nice feeling by reading this types of things…thanks…
Erotic Stories
I`d like to say that you always offer accurate information and I have been an long term reader of your site for quite some time. Just wanted to say thank you really for all the good work you do, and if you are interested in a linkexchange with 3 of my websites please contact me via e-mail. I want to say you always provide accurate information, I’ve always been a regular reader of your web site for a long time. Water Damage St Louis MI
I just want to say I am all new to blogs and absolutely liked you’re blog site. I truly enjoy reading on this internet site. You definitely have really good articles. Regards for revealing your web page.
vakantiehuisje frankrijk
This article does not address two-earner/two-parent families, where fathers uphold their responsibility to their children to do half the unpaid work of raising them and mothers take financial responsibility for themselves and half the contribution toward children’s expenses.
cdl test killer | exam2home.com
This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works.
custom paper
Not sure why any of these guys are branded losers. It’s a ridiculous article. Levi, Tejay and Joe (especially Joe) are all fantastic athletes that deserve our support. A big thumbs down to bicycle magazine. emergency water damage Dallas TX