The Midwest’s troubles are well-known. The decline of manufacturing has resulted in job losses and dying industrial towns. The best and brightest have fled the flatlands for more exciting, sunnier, mountainous, or coastal places where the real action is. Even Peyton Manning has left the heartland for the Rockies.
This narrative is so deeply embedded both in and outside of the Midwest that many people overlook the ways in which parts of the region are bouncing back. The Midwest’s story is important because it serves in significant ways as a regional microcosm of how growth and opportunity should look in America today.
In a recent study we look at trends that upend the conventional wisdom about the Midwest. We find that it is neither doomed to a slow and dirty demise like an old house on an eroding slope, nor forced to reinvent itself Dubai-style in order to compete with Silicon Valley or Manhattan. The Midwest’s future is rooted very much in its past—but with some important updates.
What do we mean? For starters, this means capitalizing on Americans’ desire to reside where the cost of living and doing business is favorable. As the last Census showed, Americans move in droves to regions where the cost of living is low, businesses face fewer obstacles, and workers have choices. As Wendell Cox and Joel Kotkin have shown, this goes for 25- to 35-year-olds as well as 55- to 65-year-olds. People want options and a good quality of life at a price they can afford.
In the Midwest, these trends have favored placed like Columbus, Ohio, and Indianapolis, Indiana. When people hear “Midwest,” they are more likely to think of this kind of picture:
The blue areas show destinations to which people from Detroit have moved between 2000 and 2010. The brown shades are the areas from which Detroit has drawn people. Given Detroit’s well-publicized decline, all the blue should be no surprise.
But a respectable portion of the Midwest looks like this:
And this:
Like most parts of America, Columbus and Indianapolis have seen a net outmigration southward to Florida and Texas. No surprise there. But note how both cities are stealing population from Chicago, Detroit, New York, and even southern California and Miami in Indianapolis’s case. The maps also show how intense interstate competition within the Midwest is right now.
One important measure of the cost of living is housing affordability, which is typically set at 3.0 as a measure of median housing price divided by median income. Compared to San Francisco at 7.2, New York at 6.1, Los Angeles at 5.9, and Miami at 4.7, Columbus stands at 2.8 and Indianapolis at 2.4. Charlotte, which has been an exemplary Sun Belt growth magnet for a while, stands at 3.9, a slight click above the Chicago area’s 3.8.
Affordability and overall quality of life as measured by schools and greater disposable income matter a lot—even to technology entrepreneurs. Some Midwestern areas are outpacing coastal areas on this front. In a recent Forbes ranking of tech growth in the nation’s largest 51 metro areas, the Midwest had three cities within the top 15, with Columbus in third position, followed by Indianapolis and St. Louis.
But it would be wrong for tech boosters to think the Midwest’s future rests in harnessing the power of this sector alone. Rather, it’s a combination of brains and brawn that signify the Midwest’s core strength. When we look at Midwestern areas that have experienced above-average growth in bachelor’s degrees, there are important overlaps with areas experiencing above-average growth in manufacturing, too.
In the corridor from Madison to Milwaukee, or the outlying areas around Chicago, or the Indianapolis metro area, or even in the Quad Cities on the Iowa-Illinois border, we see higher educational attainment and manufacturing growth occurring together. Cedar Rapids, Iowa, had the highest GDP growth from 2000 to 2010 of any metro area in the Midwest. A new corridor has grown up between Cedar Rapids and Iowa City, home to the University of Iowa; it takes advantage of the region’s historical manufacturing capacity and blends it with new technology. Peoria, Illinois, is second to Cedar Rapids in GDP growth. Peoria is home to 200 manufacturing firms, and it is also a Midwestern leader in college degree attainment.
Manufacturing continues to be part of the regional DNA in the Midwest. Trying to move away from it would be a fool’s errand, as this picture shows:
The concentration of manufacturing in middle America is a real asset, especially when combined with higher levels of educational attainment, as we have seen. The Midwest is still home to much of the nation’s skilled labor force. And contrary to the declinist narrative mentioned at the outset, the region has added 50,000 “heavy metal” manufacturing jobs since 2009.
The challenge for the region, actually, will perhaps be filling manufacturing jobs rather than creating them. A recent Deloitte survey found that 83 percent of manufacturers nationwide suffered a moderate or severe shortage of skilled production workers. The Midwest is poised to establish what we call a “new industrial paradigm,” characterized by a blend of heavy manufacturing, new technology, a more highly educated industrial labor base, and lighter labor restrictions (Indiana just became a right-to-work state, and the much-publicized debates in Wisconsin and Ohio over labor laws have only served to draw more attention to the need for reform, whatever the near-term effects). When you add to all of this the new energy sources discovered in some parts of the Midwest—such as new finds in Utica shale in Ohio—a new industrial paradigm in the region could end up being a large source of new wealth creation in the coming generation.
So why might the Midwest be something of a microcosm for how growth and opportunity look in America as a whole, given its idiosyncratic reliance on manufacturing not shared by other regions? The main reason is that middle America is a clear picture of how much the basics matter: Cost of living, job quality, schools, and opportunities to develop the right skills for the best jobs. The areas within the Midwest that have gotten the basics right are poaching people and companies from the areas that haven’t. Any economic development strategy that ignores the basics in favor of a more stylized theory of growth will usually run off the rails before too long. Americans, at the end of the day, want the places they live to get the basics right so they themselves can build their lives, start their businesses, and raise their children as they wish.
This piece originally appeared at The American.
This peice was adapted from a recent report: "Clues from the Past: The Midwest as an Aspirational Region." Download the full pdf version of the report, including charts and maps about the Great Lakes Region.
Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and is a distinguished presidential fellow in urban futures at Chapman University, and contributing editor to the City Journal in New York. He is author of The City: A Global History. His newest book is The Next Hundred Million: America in 2050, released in February, 2010.
Mark Schill is Vice President of Research at Praxis Strategy Group, an economic development and research firm working with communities and states to improve their economies.
Ryan Streeter is Distinguished Fellow for Economic and Fiscal Policy at the Sagamore Institute. You can follow his work at RyanStreeter.com and Sagamoreinstitute.org.
Great Lakes Freighter photo by BigStockPhoto.com.
Comments
33 responses to “Right in the Middle: The Midwest’s Growth Lessons for America”
You write as if members of “the population” are gold coins. It’s not that simple. The origination matters far more than the destination, if you’re claiming these patterns within the Midwest provide any gauge of the future. So what if a greater number of people from NYC moved to Columbus than left to NYC? I mean, I get it: the more talented, skilled, and educated households are generally more geographically mobile. But I’ve yet to see any inkling of – dare I say – evidence to suggest that the frequent focus on recession-era migration patterns will prevail and ultimately influence the long-term geography of our economy. WHO is moving from NYC to Ohio, or from Southern California to Indianapolis, is far more important than the volume of migration.
I think you’re right though. The midwest will be fine, and it doesn’t need to entirely reinvent itself to be fine. I just find it weak to placate to the knuckleheads who can only recognize this (the Midwest being fine…) if you highlight net positive migration patterns and an implied resurgence in old school manufacturing. An influx of people, high college-education rates in tiny Midwest towns (Peoria), and manufacturing isn’t why the Midwest will be “okay.” The Midwest will be okay because it’s still, and always will be, at the geographic center of major domestic consumer markets.
Belgravia Villas is also near elite schools in Singapore such as Rosyth School, Anderson Primary and Xinmin Primary School. Renowned international schools – Chatsworth International School and Lycee Francais De Singapour are also nearby. belgravia villas
I finally found great post here.I will get back here. I just added your blog to my bookmark sites. thanks.Quality posts is the crucial to invite the visitors to visit the web page, that’s what this web page is providing. http://www.rebelmouse.com
If Amtrak delivers a train to them on time, most of them keep it on time. Amtrak even pays some of the railroads to keep trains on time, which gives them a powerful disincentive to shunt passenger trains aside. ford t-shirt
Recent times when net has so often gossip mongering and clog; your proportion really refreshes me. Svenska Artiklar
I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job! acne no more book mike walden
The terminology used to define a set of episodes about Salmon-Safe action, are produced by a television series varies from country Graphic designers Brisbane
BeerTapTV covers the Beer Lifestyle from all over the globe. For me it is important fishing for King salmon nea start potty training
BeerTapTV covers the Beer Lifestyle from all over the globe. For me it is important fishing for King salmon nea. fotografos valencia
The terminology used to define a set of episodes about Salmon-Safe action, are produced by a television series varies from country to country ebooks with resale rights
Excellent post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful information particularly the last part no flame e cig
This development is near to Downtown East, the ultimate entertainment centre in the East. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends is therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities near Sea Horizon EC.. garcinia cambogia extract
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article to learn more, online paralegal programs I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own Blog.
Information
Visa on arrival
Live Journal Cao
Vietnam tour blogs
Joanna Blog
Amilavey Blog
Vietnam visa blog
How to get vietnam visa ?
Antondark inube
Visa for vietnam edu blog
Vietnam visa information
In a recent Forbes ranking of tech growth in the nation’s largest 51 metro areas, the Midwest had three cities within the top 15, with Columbus in third position, followed by Indianapolis and St. Louis…..free cell phone spy software
cell phone spyware
This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more … good luck skintervention
I read some thing comparable to this post via google news… I became interested and then started looking around, and landed at this site… in any case, I think that I mostly agree with what you discuss here. But I am going to go see what else I can lookup too best ecigs
Burn The Fat Feed The Muscle : Tom Venuto Reveals The Little-Known Secret Celebrities, Bodybuilders, And Fitness Models Use To Stay “Photo Ready” Fit. No Magic Pills. No Extreme Diets. No Living At The Gym. Burn The Fat Feed The Muscle : Quick And Permanent Fat Loss Doesn’t Have To Be Torture… capture his heart pdf download
We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work. print banner
This will be one of the most important festivals for many people. Everyone already knows that the quality of Apple is unquestionable. There are many people who are very dependent. buy bong uk
Here I would say my big thanks to the writer of the site for having such nice collections which are totally intresting and informative for me.Thanks a lot again buy swiss watches online
This will be one of the most important festivals for many people. Everyone already knows that the quality of Apple is unquestionable. There are many people who are very dependen Business Intelligence
This will be one of the most important festivals for many people. Everyone already knows that the quality of Apple is unquestionable. There are many people who are very dependent guaranteed phone contracts
We were able to provide you with some of the facts above but there is still plenty more to write about in subsequent articles.check cheap online booking in less rates Air Condition Pasadena
This will be one of the most important festivals for many people. Everyone already knows that the quality of Apple is unquestionable. There are many people who are very dependent Eu Voices
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that Graviditetstest
This is a great post, it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it how to last longer in bed
Bei mir leben die Apps mehr denn je. Wenn ich mich morgens mit der Bahn auf den Weg zur Arbeit mache, freue ich mich jedesmal auf einen Kaffee und mein Tablet mit den gängigen Zeitungen. Ich möchte darauf nicht mehr verzichte lajmi lajmet e fundit lajme shqip nga kosova
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that alldesignerglasses
This is a great post, it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it piano for all
Really it is nice post, The post is clearly highlighting the values of law. It is now being necessary for all of us to understand law and its values katze vermisst
Make Small Talk Sexy: The Conversation Secrets That Help You Crawl Into A Woman’s Mind And Activate Her Libido Almost Like Magic. This site is a leading resource for information about the Bobby Rio Make Small Talk Sexy PDF book and conversation escalation bitskin abzocke
Make Small Talk Sexy: The Conversation Secrets That Help You Crawl Into A Woman’s Mind And Activate Her Libido Almost Like Magic. This site is a leading resource for information about the Bobby Rio Make Small Talk Sexy PDF book and conversation escalation. Auto-Angebote
One problem with post- funding is that the interconnections are so complex it could take years to untangle it and assign blame accurately, especially if firms are actively concealing activity. SEG Media Group