When the satirical humor weekly The Onion announced it was moving its editorial staff from New York to Chicago it was considered quite a coup by boosters of the Windy City. Yet the hoopla surrounding revealed more about Chicago’s decline as a media center than any significant uptick. This includes news of a staff rebellion at the Onion in which writers attempted to scotch the move, with some ultimately deciding not to come. The strong celebration of a relatively small relocation in the grand scheme of things also shows a city looking hard for good media news where there has been so much bad recently.
The biggest blow of the all has been the end of the Oprah Winfrey show and her departure for Los Angeles to start a new network. She was the one legitimate mega-star who came from Chicago and built an empire recognizably Chicago-based. When she left, her network, which has struggled to obtain distribution and viewers, carried a Rosie O’Donnell talk show based in Chicago that ultimately folded as well. Similarly, Playboy, another iconic Chicago media brand, also departed for LA.
Some of this reflects national trends that have led to a greater concentration of media in New York and, to some extent, Washington. All across America, local media has struggled. The Tribune, Sun-Times, and alt-weekly Chicago Reader all went bankrupt, and while they continue to publish, they have become in many respects shadows of their former selves. New mayor Rahm Emanuel, while still engaging with local media, has frequently decided to bypass it, going directly to major national media to get the city’s story out. For example, he hosted New York Times columnist Tom Friedman, resulting in a fawning profile.
Daley also had occasional good luck with the national media, getting glowing stories in publications like the Economist and the New Yorker. Many of these read like classic Sunday travel section pieces in their boosterism. One possible reason for that is that they are travel pieces. Chicago never had a huge number of national bureaus, and the number has shrunk in the past few years because of the difficulty in supporting a national footprint generally. For example, the Washington Post closed all of its bureaus, and the Chicago bureau was a casualty. Today most national news outlets don’t have a boots on the ground perspective of the city, and thus are open to being spun by clever locals.
This lack of out of town and foreign media means that what coverage Chicago does get is often positive, but the flip side is that Chicago doesn’t have a built in platform for getting its message out nationally or globally. New York is America’s media center. DC, LA, and the Bay Area all have a robust out of town media presence because of the industries based there (government, entertainment, and tech respectively). They have a megaphone to the world that Chicago doesn’t. That’s perhaps one reason Emanuel made what many consider an ill-advised play for the NATO summit: it was a rare opportunity to showcase Chicago to global journalists.
Chicago also falls short in new media. In many cities, the decline of the daily paper has been offset by a robust new media infrastructure. This includes sites like Crosscut in Seattle or MinnPost in the Twin Cities. Major national sites like Gawker or the Huffington Post have tended to be based in traditional media center like New York or Washington. Chicago has been curiously absent here. An attempt at a non-profit online new site, the Chicago News Cooperative, failed due to financial difficulties, despite seven figures in funding from the MacArthur Foundation and a contract with the New York Times.
Where major platforms have arisen in Chicago, they’ve often left in order to pursue their ambitions. For example, music site Pitchfork, which started out of a music festival in Chicago, moved its editorial staff to Brooklyn. Statistical journalist Nate Silver likewise moved to New York.
The challenge facing media and journalists in Chicago was best perhaps summed up by JC Gabel, a die hard fan of the city. He relaunched the historic Chicagoan magazine in an effort to rebuild the sort of infrastructure the city once had. He wrote in the launch issue:
By all accounts, it should be an exciting time to live and work in Chicago. But there is little well-paid creative work available for the hungry freelancers—the writers, artists, photographers, editors and designers—who call Chicago home. Locally, what work there is pays a pittance; nothing that could sustain the kind of long-form storytelling we were discussing.
This might help explain the mass exodus from Chicago of creative minds of our generation throughout the last few years. Opportunities on either coast—or overseas—eventually come calling, and although they retain pride in their erstwhile Midwestern hearts, they cease to be Chicagoans by physical address.
Stop Smiling, the magazine I co-edited and co-published for more than a decade from Chicago, ultimately couldn’t have made it without also keeping a New York office and a strong West Coast presence. By and large, a majority of stories were executed in Los Angeles or New York, and all the money we raised through ad sales came right out of the agency machines on either coast. But Chicago was always our inspiration, a place where we retired to—first to brood, then to get our work done.
I know firsthand how difficult it is to carve out a national niche audience in a city that many still consider fly-over country, despite its rich history and inventive spirit.
Part of the challenge for Chicago lies in the ongoing changes being wrought by the internet and globalization. These are both spreading around some activities and ever more concentrating others. Media is among those undergoing further centralization into the handful of fortress hubs, notably New York and DC. This has hit Chicago, always a second-tier media center, hard.
But the good news is that Chicago is full of talented folks like Gabel with a passion for their city. Chicago actually does have the critical mass of talent to support a far stronger media ecosystem than it has today. And with the low barriers in the internet age, there’s no insurmountable obstacles to making that happen. But clearly anyone trying to make a go of it in media in Chicago today is swimming upstream against a fast flowing current of decline.
Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs and the founder of Telestrian, a data analysis and mapping tool. His writings appear at The Urbanophile.
Tribune tower photo by Bigstockphoto.com.
Comments
31 responses to “The Collapse of Chicago Media”
It is true that, in absolute numbers, Chicago ranks in the second tier of media centers and that the industry as a whole has been subjected to changes caused by globalization and the internet, but the story of a collapse in Chicago’s media industry is not true.
Using an empirical methodology, as opposed to the anecdotal evidence provided in the article, one will find the media industry in Chicago rises and falls in tandem with NY and LA. Furthermore, there is no discernible pattern of a “fast flowing current of decline” in Chicago.
The US Bureau of Economic Analysis hosts a regional database for employment and income by NAICS industry. A comparison of the information and arts industries in the Chicago, Los Angeles and New York MSAs from 2001 – 2010 generally shows the three metro areas exhibit the same trends in compensation and employment. The links below direct to the interactive data tables at the BEA. For a graphic view, click the chart icon on the right and then the radio button for each metro area. Here’s a look at the numbers.
All three metros had lower levels of employment in the information industry in 2010 than in 2001. Chicago ranks 3rd with an index (2001 = 100) score of 72.7, NY 78.5 and LA 82.5. The trend line for all three is similar, and NY and CHI are very close. In absolute numbers, Chicago ranks 4th behind NY, LA and DC.
Total full-time and part-time employment by NAICS industry Private employment: Information (index) http://1.usa.gov/LZFian
Rather than writing the same conclusions (similar trends in all three cities; Chicago is not an outlier) for the various metrics, I’ve assembled them below. After viewing a few of the charts, I wonder if anyone could spot the alleged collapse in Chicago.
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Information (percent change from preceding period) http://1.usa.gov/LScyFL
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Information (index) http://1.usa.gov/LS9kC8
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Publishing industries, except Internet (index) http://1.usa.gov/MNA95K
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Internet publishing and broadcasting (index) http://1.usa.gov/LSdzO0
Total full-time and part-time employment by NAICS industry Private employment: Arts, entertainment, and recreation (index) http://1.usa.gov/LS50Tk
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Arts, entertainment, and recreation (percent change from preceding period) http://1.usa.gov/LZQAey
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Arts, entertainment, and recreation (index) http://1.usa.gov/LZMwLt
Compensation of employees by NAICS industry Private compensation: Performing arts and spectator sports (index) http://1.usa.gov/LZLiQe
This is exactly what I was looking for. Produced me in my view believe it from so many various angles. After examine a few of the blog posts on your web site now, and I really like your manner of blogging.
Regrad – toko tas branded wanita
Great post, sounds good bark collar
Wonderful post!This is very useful to many readers like me. Well, I appreciate your efforts in creating this post however I believe you should take the time and Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I will be sure to bookmark your blog.
Inventure India is a management consulting firm has an unparalleled depth of knowledge and resources combined with functional and industry expertise for geographical reach. We help leaders make distinctive, lasting and substantial enhancement to the performance of their organizations.
Business opportunities in india
Excellent post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful information particularly the last part I care for such information a lot. I was looking for this certain info for a long time. Thank you and best of luck. – Hotel Murah Semarang
This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article! That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this! – sewa sound system
you’re posting an incredible post talk about reliable information its step-up my own information creating amount is to high quality quickly realize over-all great work. you can visit Media buying in Dubai get cheap Advertising agency in Dubai and buying many other Digital media Dubai services.
Il ya de nombreuses étapes d’un sujet où j’ai été trop étonné de lire la stratégie et les questions controversées, écrite par vous. Mais je suis heureux de lire que vous avez porté tous les avantages et les inconvénients du sujet.
Alarme piscine homologuée
We appreciate a work of the all people that share information with me and others. My self really impressed with this news site. Very Simple and clear explanation of issues is given and it is open for everyone. Ontra
whatiswebsdesign Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your blog and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently quickly.
I believe that we were all aware that it was going to happen sooner or later. Anyway, I believe that things will get better someday. I will check this website more often for other news on this.
I liked your site, thank you very much for your work! … Thank you so much for the information! … It has long been looking for something similar, that’s stumbled on this site.
x 1round2serif font
Just found your website and I am actually very happy about it because the content is interesting. I Have learned a couple of new things from this article which definitely will come in handy in the feature so thank you for that.http://www.aftec.com
I always like your blog post because you always come with different ideas and information. I always shared your site post with my friends. Keep posting and i will follow you..
free cell phone spy software
cell spyware
Chicago’s decline as a media center than any significant uptick. plumbing and heating nj
Good share of this wonderful job. thanks.
hermes birkin
But clearly anyone trying to make a go of it in media in Chicago today is swimming upstream against a fast flowing current of decline. interior house painters
smart wireless scanner is a hand held,protable smallest scanner,scanning pen – Smart Electronicsdinner in the desert
Thank you for the information, will be following your blog with a greatest interest. I think this post is very beneficial and valuable for medical student. Keep posting. I was just looking for this information and got it here now. You’ve such a wonderful website. Keep sharing and cheers for good work here. – baju korea murah
“In times of profound change, the learners inherit the earth, while the learned find themselves beautifully equipped to deal with a world that no longer exists.”
sari blouse online
Chicago that ultimately folded as well. Similarly, Playboy, another iconic Chicago media brand, also departed for LA. Wonga Promo code
Some of this reflects national trends that have led to a greater concentration of media in New York and, to some extent, Washington. All across America, local media has struggled. roofing toms river nj
Thanks for sharing the information. Love your idea on the topic. Looking forward for more interesting posts.
wheel aligner | car hoist
Washington. All across America, local media has struggled. The Tribune, Sun-Times, and alt-weekly Chicago Reader all went bankrupt, http://www.nocreditcheckcarloans.net/
I do wish there were more people like you around on the interwebs. I never read such beautiful article before. This article is very unique and full of surprise. I nver read this kind of article that is straighforward when regarding to the topic. Very intense kind of writing. Keep up the good and unique article writing. – baju hamil
Thanks for sharing the information. Love your idea on the topic. Looking forward for more interesting posts
http://www.diypergolakits.net/
nice
http://www.lifeinsurancerates.com/
good
http://www.personalcashadvance.com/
GOOD
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SnMgW61ncM8“>pure garcinia cambogia
GOOD
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SnMgW61ncM8