In the mid-1950s, the McGuire Sisters’ version of Johnny Mercer’s song about what happens when an irresistible force meets an immovable object made it to number five on the record charts. Their prediction, that “Something’s Gotta Give,” provides an apt description of the outcome of today’s battle between the parents of Millennials who want more say in their children’s education and the teacher unions and school district administrators who refuse to give up a smidgeon of control over the public schools they run.
One of the hottest battle fronts in the war between these two forces has been debates over whether to adopt “Parent Trigger” laws, similar to those passed in California in 2010. Such legislation empowers the majority of parents in any school district deemed to be “failing,” according to the federal No Child Left Behind standards, to essentially reconstitute the school according to parents’ desires either by turning it into a charter school or removing and replacing all current teachers and administrators.
Since 2010, Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana have passed similar legislation and it is up for debate in major industrial states such as Michigan, Pennsylvania and New York. In Florida, the idea came within one vote of passage in the State Senate thanks to the enthusiastic support of former Florida Republican Governor, Jeb Bush. At the same time, such Democratic stalwarts as Barack Obama’s Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, and liberal Congressman George Miller (D-CA) have expressed their strong support for the concept. Most recently, the bi-partisan U.S. Conference of Mayors unanimously passed a resolution in support of Parent Trigger laws. Los Angeles Mayor, Antonio Villaraigosa, chairman of both the Mayor’s Conference and the upcoming Democratic National Convention, led the charge for the resolution’s passage, aided by strong support from Democratic Mayors such as Michael Nutter of Philadelphia and Kevin Johnson of Sacramento.
None of this has softened the resistance from teacher unions, historically a bulkwark of Democratic support. Often led by unreconstructed Boomer liberals from the 1960s, they see the law’s emphasis on parental prerogatives as the ultimate threat to their control of the classroom and educational budgets. In the most recent battle, unions were able to pressure Change.org, a for profit, grass roots website “staffed by some of the most talented progressive organizers in the country,” to bar StudentsFirst, an advocacy group run by Democrat Michelle Rhee, the former Washington D.C. School Superintendent, that supports giving parents more control over the schools their children attend, from using its website.
And when the chief press person for Parent Revolution, the non-profit that is the primary driver behind the adoption of Parent Trigger laws, was announced as the new education media spokesperson by Obama’s re-election campaign, teachers’ unions threatened to withhold their support of the president.
In the long run, the implacable objections of the unions to parents having more say over the type of education their own children will fail. They will prove no match for the irresistible force of generational change that is already sweeping away existing institutional power structures in schools across the country.
One of the distinguishing characteristics of Millennials, born 1982-2003, is the intense interest their parents take in every aspect of their children’s lives. This desire to constantly hover over their offspring earned parents of older Millennials (those now in their twenties) the sobriquet, “helicopter parents.” The younger half of the Millennial Generation, which accounts for most elementary and all secondary school students today is primarily parented by members of the more entrepreneurial Generation X (born 1965-1981). These parents replaced their Boomer predecessors’ tendency to hover and talk with a desire to take action and change bottom-line results.
Millennials are the largest, most diverse generation in American history, and many of them are now starting to have children of their own. When those children begin arriving in the nation’s schools, Millennial Generation parents will bring the same dedication that their own parents exhibited to making sure each school serves their child’s interests first. As a result, it won’t be long before the same rights California, Mississippi, Texas, and Louisiana parents now have are given to every parent in the country. As Ben Austin, the founder of the Parent Revolution points out, “the old coalitions don’t apply here; it’s a cause that unites parents from upper-middle-class and working-class backgrounds—white, black, and Latino alike.”
The type of generational change America will experience over the next few decades will drive the transformation of America’s educational institutions and overwhelm those who attempt to keep parents from deciding what kind of school their kids go to. When push comes to shove, something’s gotta give. And, in the end, that means that those who stand for the status quo in our nation’s schools will have to give up their traditional prerogatives and let parents choose the educational experience they think is best for their own children.
Morley Winograd and Michael D. Hais are co-authors of the newly published Millennial Momentum: How a New Generation is Remaking America and Millennial Makeover: MySpace, YouTube, and the Future of American Politics and fellows of NDN and the New Policy Institute.
School bus photo by BigStockPhoto.com.
Comments
18 responses to “Public School Parent Trigger Laws: Something’s Gotta Give”
So local control of schools is fine except when it is not. The solution is to run for the school boards, and then push from there. Of course there does need to be the following qualification about the new schools, all are accepted into the system (no entrance tests) and its first come first served to each schoool. The idea is that the charter schools and the like may not cherry pick.
This week was pretty normal at Guaranteed Search Engine Optimization| work there was no camping in the extreme cold or dealing with animals in the middle of the night.
Guaranteed SEO|
SEO Guaranteed|
There are very few areas that have erosion threats, so our main focus is to fall hazard trees that will end up blocking the trail and extensive brush removal.SEO Guarantee|
good kelebek chat
interesting post, thanks for the useful article. montana
Cameron says that it is wrong if people can continue not to appear before select committees. He says Sir George Young, the leader of the Commons, may look at this. themodernseo
We all know that objections of the unions to parents having more say over the type of education their own children will fail. They will prove no match for the irresistible force of generational change that is already sweeping away existing institutional power structures in schools across the country. check this
Business growth is the result of success. When you have grown your business pay close attention to what exactly put you in that position. You can capitalize on the small facet of your business that put you in a position for growth. nigerian stock exchange
search engine optimization packages This is best site to spent time on .I just stumbled upon your chatty blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your very well written blog posts. I will be your frequent visitor, that’s search engine optimization package
El Torero|
sizzling hot gratis spielen| It is plausible to see the images as they seem anyplace on the screen. Kindly note once the image develops 2-5 times, the payline will join the compensating image. Would you be able to visualize how the book of ra connected spielen will join your wages? It’s no longer simply speculation once you drop in this amusement. Remember, the reward is legitimately regulated by the image itself. Thus all we can declare is come unite the amusement.
I am really impressed by this excellent stuff. Rialto Garage Door Repair This is my first time to visit your blog and I found very useful knowledge you done a great job, Keep more posting like this.
you did nice work your post is awesome its increase my knowledge.the post is best i can never read before this type of post nice sharing. keep it up buy auto blogs | buy wiki backlinks | buy google plus
This battle is so much unexpected.It could harm the children’s education.But teacher’s association should give some privileges to parents also.I wanna read more about this.
This is a very good way of helping children to become more passionate about reading. More people should provide support in giving away free books to children.
Books are very important medium in helping kids their age to develop their skills and knowledge.
Juniper
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it, I have you bookmarked to check out all the new stuff you post.It’s the extraordinary in arts that makes it more interesting.
paper help at WiseEssays.com
Sometimes you may feel tired continually? Is it possible to stop snoring? May be the physician obtaining trouble coping with your own higher bloodstream supply stress? In case you clarified “yes” to the people questions, your interest in needs may have Anti Snoring (also called Clogging Stop snoring or perhaps OSA).
These repeated awakenings bring about fragmentation regarding night time period sleep. You do not bear in mind them being that they are so quick. Actually, individuals with stop snoring can wake-up more than 30 occasions 1 hour roughly snoring around and believe that they rested continuous while using the night time. Because rest has to be constant as well as combined to be effective at be restorative healing healing, numerous cognitive issues may appear having sleep fragmentation: day time drowsiness, storage difficulties, awareness troubles, mental instability, frustration, slowed down reduce reduced reaction time, and more importantly, any elevated chance of car incidents.
Hold on, how genuine are these concerns? The Food and drug administration just approved cinnamon and cherry-flavored nicotine lozenges, along with the anti-smoking groups expressed no concern over people items.
I do not think there’s any question the lozenges pose a far greater danger of youth abuse than e-cigarettes. Why? Being that they are easily available and comparatively affordable, since the electric cigarettes need a youth to take a position out one hundred dollars, which does not ask them to the tubes.
This does not imply there is not problems with e-cigarettes that should be addressed. This does not imply e-cigarette producers should not be requested to make sure changes, for example instituting tight qc techniques and making sure greenavis ecigs the propylene glycol is missing of diethylene glycol. This does not imply there should not be limitations around buying people products to minors. Nonetheless it requires it’s lunacy to prevent the product, especially taking into consideration the way exactly the same Food and drug administration has become approving the well-regarded as as deadly Marlboros, Winstons, Kools, Newports, Camels, while some.
verys
–klima servisi
arçelik klima servisi
vestel klima servisi
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on this topic Lowcost hotels . And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him. So I should thank you for the free lunch I got.