After a decade of increasingly celebrated gentrification, many believe Brooklyn — the native borough of both my parents — finally has risen from the shadows that were cast when it became part of New York City over a century ago. Brooklyn has gotten “its groove back” as a “post-industrial hotspot,” the well-informed conservative writer Kay Hymowitz writes, a perception that is echoed regularly by elements of a Manhattan media that for decades would not have sullied their fingers writing about the place.
And to be sure, few parts of urban America have enjoyed a greater public facelift — at least in prominent places — than New York’s County of Kings, home to some 2.5 million people. The borough is home to four of the nation’s 25 most rapidly gentrifying ZIP codes, notes a recent Fordham study. When you get a call from the 718 area code these days, it’s as likely to be from your editor’s or investment bankers’ cell as from your grandmother.
Yet there’s a darker side to the story. This became clear to me not long ago when driving with my wife and youngest daughter to a friend’s house in the Ditmas Park section of Flatbush, one of the finest exemplars of urban renaissance in the country. We encountered a huge traffic jam on the Belt Parkway, so we exited on Linden Boulevard. For the next half hour we drove through an expanse of poverty, public housing and general destitution that hardly jibes with the “hip, cool” image Brooklyn now projects around the world.
A look at the numbers shows this was not an isolated experience. Despite the influx of hipsters and high-income sophisto professionals, Brooklyn is home to one of New York State’s poorest populations, with over one in five residents under the official poverty line, roughly 50 percent above the state average. This likely understates the problem since the cost of living in the borough is now the second-highest in the nation to Manhattan, surpassing even high-tone San Francisco.
Overall, despite some job gains, the borough’s unemployment rate stood at 11 percent this summer, up from 9.7 percent a year ago and well above the national average. Much of recent job growth has been in lower-wage industries, notes Martin Kohli, chief regional economist with the Bureau of Labor Statistics in New York City. Despite a much celebrated start-up scene, some 30,000 of the 50,000 jobs created since the recession have been in the generally low-wage health care and social assistance sector, with another 9,000 in the hospitality industry.
Poverty citywide, meanwhile, has been rising for three years running and the real Brooklyn, roughly half non-white, remains surprisingly poor. Brooklyn’s median per capita income in 2009 was just under $23,000, almost $10,000 below the national average.
So what’s going on here? Urban historian Fred Siegel, a longtime Brooklyn resident, sees a classic tale of two cities. “Brownstone and Victorian Brooklyn is booming,” he says, due in part to uncle Ben Bernanke‘s inflationary policies, which have bailed out the Wall Street banks whose profits are the bedrock of New York City’s prosperity. This money has now spread to those parts of “Manhattanized” Brooklyn closest to the core of the Big Apple, with bankers, lawyers and the like opting to settle in more human-scale neighborhoods.
But lower middle-class Brooklyn “is pockmarked with empty stores,” Siegel notes. With its once robust industrial- and port-based economy shrunken to vestigial levels, opportunities for Brooklynites who lack high-end skills or nice inheritances are shrinking. Some other areas, like Bensonhurst and Sheepshead Bay, have been revived through immigration.
Jonathan Bowles, president of the New York-based Center for an Urban Future, sees a divide between, on the one hand, “the creative class” and some immigrant neighborhoods, and on the other, “the concentrated poverty” in many other struggling areas like Brownsville (where my mother grew up) and East New York. “There are clearly huge swaths of Brooklyn where you don’t see gentrification and there won’t be anytime soon,” Bowles observes.
Part of the problem is structural. Many of Brooklyn’s working-class commuters — particularly in the eastern end of the borough — depend on a transit system designed to funnel people into the giant office clusters of Manhattan. Those left looking for work in the borough, often in low-paid service jobs, face long commutes or have to get a car, a big expense in a city with ultra-high rents, taxes and insurance costs.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s administration identifies itself closely with Manhattan’s “luxury city” economy. Focused on finance, media and high-end business services, this approach does not offer much to blue-collar Brooklyn. New York over the past decade has suffered among the worst erosions of its industrial base of any major metropolitan area. Brooklyn alone has lost 23,000 manufacturing jobs during that time.
Inequality in the Bloombergian “luxury city” is growing even faster than in the nation as whole. In fact, the gap between rich and poor is now the worst in a decade. New York’s wealthiest one percent earn a third of the entire city’s personal income — almost twice the proportion for the rest of the country.
So while artisanal cheese shops serve the hipsters and high-end shops thrive, one in four Brooklynites receives food stamps.
We see similar patterns across even the most vibrant of the nation’s urban regions. San Francisco gets richer with trustifarians, hedge fund managers and, for now at least, social media firms. Yet Oakland, just across the bay, suffers severe unemployment, rising crime and high vacancies. The cool bars and restaurants frequented by the creatives get the media attention, but as demographer Wendell Cox notes, roughly 80 percent of the population growth in the nation’s largest cities over the past decade consisted of people living below the poverty line.
High costs and regulatory burdens make changing this reality ever more difficult; what can be borne by Manhattan or an upscale Brooklyn neighborhood like Park Slope can devastate a grittier locale like East New York. A well-heeled banker or trust-funder may find the costs of higher taxes and regulation burdensome but still relatively trivial; such factors more strongly impact a struggling immigrant entrepreneur, or a small manufacturer, construction firm or warehouse operation. Upzonings and subsidies for real estate developers — such as those around the new Nets arena — tend to work to the benefit of high-end chains, rather than smaller, often minority-owned businesses.
Finally for all the talk, in Brooklyn and elsewhere, of a “great inversion” sending the well-to-do to cities, and what my mother would call shleppers to the suburbs, this is not the reality. Immigration and new births have supported Brooklyn’s population numbers, up 40,000 over the past decade, but as rapid outflow of Brooklynites has continued: over 460,000 more residents left than other New Yorkers or Americans moved in between 2001 and 2009, the largest loss of any borough.
These phenomena can be seen in almost every American city; anyone traveling from west Los Angeles to the east side can see the divide between the posh shops and restaurants nearer the beach and greater commercial vacancies, abandoned factories and empty offices further inland. That this is happening as well in “booming” Brooklyn is rarely acknowledged, but worth confronting. We need to learn not only how to hype “hip” cities, but think about how to restore them as aspirational places for those who aren’t members of the privileged and cool set.
Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and is a distinguished presidential fellow in urban futures at Chapman University, and contributing editor to the City Journal in New York. He is author of The City: A Global History. His newest book is The Next Hundred Million: America in 2050, released in February, 2010.
This piece originally appeared in Forbes.
Brooklyn row houses photo by Bigstock.
Comments
39 responses to “The Hollow Boom Of Brooklyn: Behind Veneer Of Gentrification, Life Gets Worse For Many”
Kevin Richards
Thanks for the insightful piece. Sometimes in our excitement at seeing inner city neighborhoods revive along with their wonderful built environments, it is important to note the populations that get pushed out and who are struggling in place. I don’t always agree with the conservative lense in which you oftentimes view American urban issues but highly agree with this one. Kudos.
Steve Sailer had some similar observations today:
http://isteve.blogspot.com/2012/09/mass-transit-v-class-transit-in-la.html
Luke Lea
When I read “When you get a call from the 718 area code these days, it’s as likely to be from your editor’s or investment bankers’ cell as from your grandmother.”, I didn’t get right away that the reference was to a cell phone. Something about ‘investment banker’ being right beside ‘cell’. It was only when I got to ‘grandmother’ that it looked odd and I re-read the sentence! I know my granny’s not in a jail cell.
We’ve been excavation with River lendors representing the yesteryear sporadic months, Santa Clarita Garage Door Repair securing the crowing interestingness grades and secured sanction representing EACH River appliers.
Good to see some light shone onto the great divide of Brooklyn. Albeit a little bit worse then I expected going into the article.
—
Jeff @ Trip2Blog.com
Trading zone where you can do entire trading, buy and sell, us trade | online selling Many people extract lot of experience during this online buying selling | online selling platform, many other think about this is a foreign exchange | online buying center, but it is wrong because it is a uk trade Like online selling
Presented by: seo learning
This place looks awesomely cool and i think i will be trying to be at the place for some of the holidays in the next vacations.
Regards,
Technology Blog
Remembering that I’ll be dead soon is the most important tool I’ve ever encountered to help me make the big choices in life. Because almost everything – all external expectations, all pride, all fear of embarrassment or failure – these things just fall away in the face of death, leaving only what is truly important.
mba case study solutions
You are more likely to add your green waste to your compost bin and worm farm if they are easily reached, on pathways free from mud. However they are also not the most attractive of essay helper things, and you probably won’t want them to be easily visible.
Great info.I like all your post.I will keep visiting this blog very often.It is good to see you verbalize from research proposal service the heart and your clarity on this important subject can be easily observed.
does it mean that it was not able to recover from way back 2012 when this article was initially posted until this day about being the Hollow Boom of Brooklyn? perhaps the economy has also change though it was not a complete turn-around but hoping to get an update about this column then. thanks.
more plays on soundcloud
These technologies can make life easier, can let us touch people we might not otherwise. You may have a child with a birth defect and be able to get in touch with other parents and support groups, get medical information, the latest experimental drugs. These things can profoundly influence life. I’m not downplaying that.
phd defense
What we see is that churches spend the most of their budgets on staff and facilities that have worship as their main purpose. buy youtube views
Thanks for taking the time to discuss and share this with us, I for one feel strongly about it and really enjoyed learning more about this topic. I can see that you possess a degree of expertise on this subject, I would very a lot like to hear much more from you on this subject matter – I have bookmarked this page and will return soon to hear additional about it. .toko lingerie
Sony NEX-3N for APS-C sensor 16.1 MP CMOS sensor and BIONZ image frame Full line of Sony Alpha 99. In particular, BIONZ chip with anti-interference ability and make good light in low light conditions which are highly appreciated. This configuration also helps the NEX series won many photography awards. Other notable strengths is the ability to autofocus quickly and accurately in a variety of circumstances.NEX-3N screen can rotate 180 degrees allowing for easy self-shooting from every angle.
Sony NEX 3N reviews
This is all probably an example of why some of us Appliance Repair Houston have the bad habit of reading footnotes first.
I don’t know the key to success, but the key to failure is trying to please everybody. whatisjobcareers.com
Thanks for taking the time to discuss and share this with us, I for one feel strongly about it and really enjoyed learning more about this topic. I can see that you possess a degree of expertise on this subject, free Photoshop tutorials
Coaster Fine Furniture 300369ke Bed, Eastern King, Beige Fabric
This elegant upholstered bed will add a sophisticated centerpiece to your contemporary master bedroom. online buysell A high slightly curved headboard and a low side and end rails are covered in a lovely textural tan fabric. The plush look is sure to complement your decor, online sell anchored by sleek dark wooden feet. Add this bed to your home to create a calming and inviting bedroom with lots of style. online buy This bed includes three metal slats and a box spring is required.
At first glance the maps seem to tell us that growing areas in the South and mountain states favor the Republicans while the declining Northeast was the stronghold of Democrats. Yet it is more complex, since states like Virginia, Florida, Colorado and even North Carolina – all with large and growing minority as well as white urban populations – vote increasingly Democratic. lipozene reviews
services where integrated services are provided by professionals to its clients seeking increased value by owning, occupying or investing in real estate. http://furniturediningchairs.com/
Proper education for Sustainable Development is must . It should include key sustainable development issues into teaching and learning.
top pathology residency programs
There are clearly huge swaths of Brooklyn where you don’t see gentrification and there won’t be anytime soon… free cell phone spy software
cell phone spyware
Recent times when net has so often gossip mongering and clog; your proportion really refreshes me.
hostmonster review
I will make certain to save your web page and may come coming back very soon. Medical Receptionist Training Sydney
Your Blog is very outstanding, I like it! Thank you for youcable steps sharing!
steroids for sale online
more info do more for the planet and take action beyond the hour. As part of our community, you’ll be kept updated with information and opportunities to participate in the …
AACR Annual Meeting 2013
Wow, the playground is really, really wide. You have acres of space to play around. Conflict Resolution Training
This occurs when drought reduces the flow of water into tree roots. non permanent hair color
Along with other New laptop notebooks is that it is extremely personalized SEO packages
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks!
Buy backlinks
high pagerank backlinks
Hi my friend! I wish to say that this post is amazing, nice written and include approximately all important infos. I would like to see more posts like this pr5 backlink buy quality backlink
This is just the information I am finding everywhere.Me and my friend were arguing about an issue similar to this! Now I know that I was right.Thanks for the information you post.
Online Ordering System
replacement kitchen doors
You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website. organic pest control
japanese mini truck parts
Finally, an issue that I am passionate about. I have looked for information of this caliber for the last several hours. Project Management Software
Info is out of this world, I would bang to see more from your writers.
free movies online
I am discovering everywhere.Me and my buddy were disagreeing about a problem just like this! Now I know that I was right. R4
A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. Agencia de Publicidad
Estudiar en el Extranjero
deca durabolin kaufen
anabolika steroide kaufen
You should write about the model/version on the blog. You can expose it’s perfect. Your blog examination should widen your readership. rebelmouse.com/jennyboltonboostyourbustreview