I recently moved to Providence, Rhode Island, where I live in the town of West Warwick. I’ve been learning the place more and soaking in New England culture (and seafood). This area has a Rust Belt type profile: declining population, post-industrial economic landscape, high unemployment, etc. So I’ve been trying to get a handle on conditions and think a bit about what the opportunities are.
I have been really struck by the way people here seem to think about their geographic identity. All of us have various layers of identity. Some of these are more primary than others. But let’s consider three possibilities in trying to answer the basic question “Where do you live?” Those are your state, your metro, or your town. Which of these forms the most important basis of identity?
My observation so far is that most people here think of themselves first as Rhode Islanders, and secondly as residents of their town. Providence, possibly because at 178,000 people it’s fairly small, is sort of seen as just another town. (Southern Massachusetts is maybe seen as a type of Canadian province with its own collection of towns).
So what? you might ask. Unit recently I probably would have said that it doesn’t matter that much. But now I see that it has a profound effect on creating the lens through which people process the world. Here are some local implications.
First, it leads people to exaggerate the uniqueness here. Rhode Island is geographically the smallest state, and also quite small in population. I heard people say that only in Rhode Island can you get pretty much every leader in the place to show up for a conference on the state’s economic future. If your worldview is the state, that may be true. But if your worldview is metro area, I think there are many similar sized regions that could pull this off. There are many things that appear unique if your lens is Rhode Island that are not if your lens is Metro Providence. It may be that there’s uniqueness in the small geography of Rhode Island from the standpoint of state policy, but if I may be so bold, this is hardly its strong suit. (But for a positive example of how this can work in a place like Rhode Island where it’s more difficult elsewhere, see the example of pension reform).
Second, the economic geography of the new economy is metro regions. When you look state first, you are missing the bigger picture. If you doubt that the metro area is the primary economic unit, I suggest spending some time perusing material over at the Brookings Institution. States are more or less irrelevant economically, except that they can screw things up for the metro and non-metro regions they contain.
Third, Providence is a bi-state metro area that includes Southern Massachusetts. You can also see Providence as an extended node in the Greater Boston economy. If you look primarily at the state, you miss this, or even see Massachusetts as the competition. You also lose about 60% of the population scale you have to work with.
Fourth, when you look state first, your natural inclination is to compare yourself against other states. In Rhode Island’s case, there really aren’t many similar places, so the default is other New England states. On the other hand, one can imagine many similar Rust Belt type metros to compare Providence too. Places like Buffalo, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland come to mind. Of course these aren’t exactly the same, but they’ve been grappling with the legacy of de-industrialization seriously for a really long time. There have got to be many things that could be learned by studying and networking with these areas. There’s a lot of pan-Rust Belt discussion going on these days, but Providence isn’t part of it. This is part of that new economic geography of cities I was talking about.
In short, I think treating state identity as primary has problems. Rhode Island is most certainly not the only place where this crops up, but it is noticeable here and perhaps more important here since the state is a subset of a metro geography instead of a superset.
Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs and the founder of Telestrian, a data analysis and mapping tool. He writes at The Urbanophile, where this piece originally appeared.
Downtown Providence photo by Bigstock.
Comments
23 responses to “Where Do You Live?”
West Warwick is not in Providence.
Your ignorance is showing.
Dave Barnes
+1.303.744.9024
Distance learning in Economics provides students with advanced knowledge in key areas such as economic applications, information usage and strategic advantage. The students are enabled in specific career and professional goals and in the areas of strategy and analysis.
anabolisant
an economy has to decide how to use its scarce resources to obtain the maximum possible satisfaction of the members of the society. It is this basic problem of scarcity which gives rise to many of the economic problems.progresser musculation
There are a number of ways in which these well qualified and trained writers can facilitate your business growth through their amazing writing services. Whether you need content for your website, for blog posts or for article submissions, good quality content can always come handy. lékué
Economists have become a new priesthood a band of putative miracle workers. Even though we don’t know much about it all, we’ve nowhere else to pin our hopes. limestone fireplaces
Major in computer graphics classes, and get a graphic arts diploma, a lot of classes in college, (or even a community college because it is cheaper and a lot of such things at the same university / college), and once made, applies in the studio and drop games iwin devopment to work.
Economics study helps the citizens decide about choosing their governments based on the overall working of the existing government in terms of management of the national funds, which again is determined by such studies.gazon synthétique
In industrial projects, there is hardly a more important component than the gate valve, they are used in most every industry in ever sector.
The electronic weighing scale machine is more commonly known as a checkweigher
, in the packaging industry. It is specifically used to improve and maintain the weight efficiency of packaged goods.
Everybody likes entertainment ,some entertain themselves by listening or singing music
others like to playing game,and bubble trouble is very tricky, you have to use the directions key to go here and there and you can shoot with the help of space key.
Every one of us is busy fighting for a better life than they having, and more and more youngsters would prefer to play Car Games example to relax because they are not time restricted and you can play them easily using short breaks between your working hours.
Dora is so cutie and make you want to touch her head and make her happy,now you have the chance to play dora games to dress this lovely girl up and make her much pretty then.
Also if you don’t know how to take care your baby as a young mother, you can play baby games online,too!
One of the most amazing things about the online food games is that they cost you nothing at all, also no matter how many times you wish to play a shopping games, you can simply get online and play it without worrying about money.
Participate in having a puppy animal dog Games or barbie stand by Cars Games in a car show to do with them similarly in actual life, You might even coach your puppy for exhibit!
Sweet little girls are always passionate about Barbie’s,who said that those barbie dress up Games are for youngsters only? These free dress up Games are really addictive, everyone enjoys a good round of taking part in these games.
Boys who love to play in the virtual world have a myriad of free boy games to choose from,for example Ben 10 Games,Mario Games ,Angry Birds Games and Racing Games.
It’s a great aspect of human nature that times of unemployment and economic instability always coincide with an increase in creative thinking and new ideas. cystite
Population decline can refer to the decline in population of any organism, but this article refers to population decline in humans. It is a term usually used to describe any great reduction in a human population. event wristbands
if your worldview is metro area, I think there are many similar sized regions that could pull this off.Supreme Hoodie
It is good to spend money, but we must be wise in our spending habits and investigate ways to get the most for our money. We are best able to manage our money and live within our means when we pay with cash, unless we have a credit card that gives special points for airline miles or other services and even then we need to make a habit of paying off our card every month to avoid late fees.estate agents glasgow
I wonder how you got so good. HaHa! This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your design is so perfect!
telefonkatalogen.biz
The island is almost like a living museum and the island is really a great place mainly for the people who are in search of employment opportunities. People comes here from different countries and many comes to spend their vacations as it is called the land of beaches. fife property
you will get economic professionals giving you a break down on different issues afflicting the economy and how this will affect you and me be it on the short term or long-term basis. bon reduction pixmania
Expect Obd2 Scanner Tool you
digimaster 3 to have a Ecu chips better article to share.Thanks for all your efforts that you have put in this. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful tacho pro 2008 article. AUTO
The future of the economy does not look promising. The GDP is likely to stay around 2%. The unemployment rate is likely to stay around 8% through 2013.
blog sur le japon