Is college worth it? The question almost seems ludicrous on its face. The unemployment rate for people with a college degree is only 4.2% versus 9.1% for people without a college degree and 13.0% for people with less than a high school education. In this economy, that should be an open and shut case.
Yet in an uncertain world, many are questioning the value of college. There’s significant talk of a “higher education bubble.” Skyrocketing tuition rates and the correspondingly high levels of student debt has driven a lot of this. Tuition has been rising at a much faster rate than inflation overall. Total student loan debt is now at $1 trillion. And unlike other forms of debt, student loans can’t be easily discharged in bankruptcy.
In many ways college finance does mirror the housing bubble. You’ve got an asset everyone believes will only go up in value, a multi-party transaction, a situation where the seller of the product (the college) gets their money up front and so is indifferent to the student’s ability to repay, third parties insured against loss by the federal government, a non-transparent market where each student is in effect charged a unique price, young and unsophisticated consumers who are told they “have to get” a college degree, financial products without any income requirements, and even worse the asset (a degree) doesn’t have a secondary market.
All of these factors create a situation ripe for exploitation and abuse. Indeed, it isn’t hard to see that the massive increases in tuition cost are heavily driven by the ability of students to get huge loans with few questions asked. And as with the housing crisis, outright fraud by educational institutions is likely more widespread than commonly believed. The University of Illinois law school falsified its admissions data, for example, by inflating its students LSAT scores. The “cockroach theory” (if you see one, there’s probably a lot more you don’t see) suggests that this type of behavior is probably rampant.
Students and their parents are starting to wise up to the game, and the amount of student loan debt they think appropriate is plummeting. For example, in 2011 only 21% of people felt $20,000 in college debt was too much. Just a year later that percentage increased to 42%. In 2008, 81% of adults thought a college degree was a good investment. In 2012 that had dropped to 57%. That’s a stunning decline in the number of people who think college is worthwhile, though it might suggest that the problem is less with the value of a degree itself than in how much is paid for it. But there are anecdotes to suggest that some feel college (especially graduate school) isn’t worth what it used to be.
Why is that? In part it is surely the economy. Though degreed adults as a whole have lower unemployment, youth unemployment and probably more important underemployment remains high for college grads. A shocking 53% of recent graduates are jobless or underemployed. This has fed through into popular culture, with student loan debt relief being part of the grab bag of demands made by the various “Occupy” movements. When you graduate from college with huge, non-dischargeable debts, and you can’t find a job, particularly in your chosen field, you no doubt complain loudly about this to your friends.
But there’s also good reason to believe college is worth less today in many cases. Back in the 1980s and 90s the value of college was clear. Manufacturing was in decline. If you didn’t have a degree, you would probably struggle. In contrast, a college degree was like a golden ticket to success.
Today, in the age of globalization, it’s not so simple. Those without degrees are still hurting, but so are plenty of people with degrees. The emerging new separation is not between those with degrees and without, but those in jobs that are subject to international competition (tradeable) vs. those that aren’t (non-tradeable). High skill, white collar workers like computer programmers suddenly found themselves in competition with much lower paid people in places like India. This upended that entire job market. Today you might be better off as an ironworker or welder whose job has to be done on site than as an accounting manager whose entire department can be sent to the Philippines. A college degree is no longer a guaranteed passport to prosperity.
Also, today’s technology driven world is changing so rapidly that skills learned in college can prove obsolete by graduation. At the same time, open source frameworks and cloud computing have dropped the cost of starting a tech business to almost literally zero. In the dot com era, it took millions of dollars to buy servers and database licenses if you wanted to start a company. Today anybody can start a technology business in his bedroom.
So if you’ve got a good idea, why wait around for graduation to get started? The role models here are Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg, who dropped out of Harvard but both got rich starting companies. This dropping out of college to start companies is actively being encouraged by some folks like Peter Thiel, who is actually paying people to do it.
What these modern day Timothy Learys overlook is what Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg already had in common. Namely, they had already gotten in to Harvard. If you make it to Harvard, you already probably come from a privileged background. Thus you’ve got a family safety net in place if things go south. Those from working class backgrounds aren’t so lucky. Indeed, I’m struck that many suggesting that college isn’t the answer are presently an upper-middle class or better situations.
For a limited number of people, dropping out of or skipping school to start a business might make sense. But trend setters may manage to convince a significant numbers of kids from marginal backgrounds to forgo the college education —perhaps in a needed skill — that would provide necessary credentials and culturally acclimate them to the new economy world. Many of those kids don’t have a family cushion to fall back on. For them, turn on, tune in, drop out is not the answer.
The real answer isn’t to skip education, but to be more judicious about the decisions being made. Racking up large amounts of debt probably isn’t the right answer. The marketing promises of especially for-profit colleges should be heavily discounted. For some, getting education through going into a skilled trade may be a good choice. College majors that don’t deliver skills in demand in the marketplace or that aren’t considered valuable credentials by employers ought to be scrutinized. But getting an education remains one of the single best decisions any person can make.
Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs and the founder of Telestrian, a data analysis and mapping tool. He writes at The Urbanophile.
Graduation photo by Bigstock.
Comments
79 responses to “Is College Worth It?”
It is not the job of a university to prepare students for the whims of the marketplace. It’s the job of universities to involve students in questioning what the marketplace has been, is, could be, and should be. Confusing the two is detrimental to both universities and the marketplace.
Price should always be a factor in college selection, though a fair amount of students are aware of this. A recent study of recent freshmen by researchers from UCLA found it is becoming a very large factor in their choice of alma mater. Get a personal finance to pay for your extra school costs.See more at:
https://personalmoneynetwork.com/cash-advance/
I call it Parking Meter Economics. Everyone racks up a pile of expensive parking tickets in San Francisco/Berkeley when they first start driving here. It takes months, sometimes years for people to learn to not get parking tickets. The first time people are offered a loan for collage, a thing all of their teachers and family have been saying is good, they jump into the loan! Almost everyone who doesn’t have experience makes this mistake. And think about it, even rape has a statute of limitation…but not student loans–even in default.
As an Economist in any of the given fields, you will interpret economic findings, prepare reports and communicate them to the management of the company the economist is employed by. For students already working in the field of economics, an economics degree online can be the gateway for students to enter into government service, nonprofit entities with careers in statistics and analysis.assurance temporaire
New and emerging economies are competing for the limited capacity of resources. Instead of having to go through all stages, they can simply advance to development. Euro Chance100
The problem of scarcity and choice making can be depicted using the tool of production possibilities curve. The basic economic problems of what, how and for whom to produce can be solved in many ways by an economy. If it gives the whole charge of the economy, to private ownership we get capitalist economy, to public ownership we get socialist economy and jointly to private and public ownership we get mixed economy.finding personalized help
The resources which fuel oil dependent economies are growing shorter in supply, as many countries like Brazil, China, and India are growing more economically strong. limestone fireplaces
The biggest shortcoming in capitalist theory is failure to quantify nature; and it is by putting a price on natural treasures and making blind practices prohibitively expensive that will be maximized ingenuity, innovation and intelligence that are the true engines of real sustainable economic growth.
click here for more details
I’m impressed. You’re truly well informed and very intelligent. You wrote something that people could understand and made the subject intriguing for everyone. I’m saving this for future use. http://www.forexprofit4tips.com
Economics is referred to the study of the factors that indicate how the resources of the society are being used and helping towards the satisfaction of the wants and needs of the people.
assurance voiturette sans permis
This time because they can’t afford them not just because they are being rational due to their educational, but because of their changed socioeconomic status. Too, more and more women are becoming the bread winners, and men don’t want to stay home and play daddy. tradestation strategies
There remains considerable theoretical debate regarding the causes, consequences and solutions for unemployment. Classical economics, New classical economics, and the Austrian School of economics argue that market mechanisms are reliable means of resolving unemployment. casino en ligne
Shop Lacoste Polo shirts from Lacoste uk outlet. Variouis Lacoste polo shirts, Lacoste shirts, Lacoste jackets, Valencia Garage Door Repair Lacoste shoes and so on are available for you with excellent quality.
The unemployed individual, in order to receive the unemployment compensation, must meet the eligibility requirements in terms of the wages earned and / or the time worked during an established period of time that is one year. NewBestApps
the coal mines due to a lack of competitiveness meant that many coal miners were unemployed and they may find it more difficult to get jobs in new industries such as computers..dermefface fx7 reviews
the cost of college tuition these days and the student loan debt these kids are taking out as of late. Not long ago, someone explained to me that they had a huge amount of potential and just needed a chance to succeed, even though they hadn’t succeeded at much in their other endeavors including school.Chiropractor Clinic Portland
Sant ritz will be available via Potong Pasir MRT place on the Northern Eastern Range. Watching bugis place as well as the town place is therefore very authentic.
It is also near to many bars along the greater serangoon place as well as NEX purchasing mall. Sant ritz also has many eateries
last thing you mention is really impressive and that is very informative one rest of the detail was also relevant, however the focus is very important Nokia prices
When i was searching i found that you have an amazing sense of honor and keen helpful material for users who came across the globe and read your stuff. quite nice sharing.
free cell phone spy software
cell spyware
I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post. Chat Random
You are more likely to add your green waste to your compost bin and worm farm if they are easily reached, on pathways free from mud. However they are also not the most attractive of things, stables and you probably won’t want them to be easily visible.
However they are also not the most attractive of things, stables and you probably won’t want them to be easily visible.
hampton bay lighting
I love them all! I teach kindergarten and I’m going essay to make a theme, and photographs have given me so many ideas! You are so talented! Thanks!
I would like to say thank for sharing this great article. We can’t get this kind of information homework helpers from anywhere.
There’s no way you could ever spend it all, and I don’t view wealth as something that validates my intelligence. buy youtube views
I wish to visit the Manor Farm for my busines study. It’s a huge farm ideal for raising all types of domestic animals as well as plant vegetable crops. realestatebestlawyer.com
The provide an easy way of partly assessing someones breathing by measuring the oxygen saturation of arterial blood pulse oximetry .
DWI Attorney Houston I daily read your blogs and give my notice for that here this article is too great and so interesting.
I’m impressed, I must say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative madeira plastica and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is hyundai hb20Soutstanding; the issue is sometallpexhing that not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.
There remains considerable theoretical debate regarding the causes, consequences and solutions for unemployment. Classical economics, New classical economics, and the Austrian School of economics argue that market mechanisms are reliable means of resolving unemployment
Nokia Mobiles
DUO Residences is also near to Bugis Junction as well as the buzzling city area. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends is therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities in Bugis.
http://duo-residence.org – Bugis condo
Installment Payday Loan Lenders can help you get the cash you need regardless of your past credit history. We offer instant approval on unsecured loans and specialize in helping people with little or no credit get the short term cash they need to make ends meet. unsecured bad credit payday loans | The road back to financial recovery is usually long and arduous. But using payday loans for bad credit improvement can be fast Payday Loans for Bad Credit
ilplaterenewal We offer the fastest Illinois license plate sticker renewals in the state. We are tied directly into the sate’s renewal database which allows us to process your request almost instantly. Illinois License Plate Registration
The three lowest handicaps are added and divided by three to establish a new pacesetting handicap. Little Black Dress
I personally believe that college is worth it, so long as you are studying a subject that you are passionate about.
Thanks for sharing and all the best,
Ryan: My Blog
As well as our many other services, we also specialise in web design so we are able to offer that extra service for many of our clients. e-Geeks understands how important it is to make your website stand out from the rest of your competitors. Cheap website design
Indeed college education is very important for a person to succeed in life. Mostly of the successful person are poor because of their perseverance to finish their college education they were able to land a good job and start their own business after they earned enough money to start their own business. We should not take for granted the opportunity to have a college education because few people can only have it, and to have it is very expensive. Investing your money in college education is a good choice because after you graduate you can already reap the money you have invested in your studies.
business storage
Lush Acres EC is also near elite schools such as Pei Hwa Secondary School, Nan Chiau Primary School, Nan Chiau High School.
For vehicle owners, it takes less than 30 minutes to drive to the business hub from Fernvale Link and Sengkang West Way vibrant Orchard Road shopping district, via Tampines Expressway (TPE), Central Expressway (CTE) and Kallang-Paya Lebar Expressway (KPE)
EC Fernvale
Installment Payday Loan Lenders makes getting approved for a bad credit payday loan fast & easy. We can help you get a loan regardless of your past credit history or credit score. We have a 95% approval rate. We can not guarantee that your loan application will be approved, but we can promise to do everything we can to help you get your loan approved. Bad Credit Loan
I have read the article, and I want to say thanks to you for exceptional information.rower machine
I want to thank you for this informative read; I really appreciate sharing this great.spotify premium
College is worth it unless you already have a business idea which you believe will make you successful.
Jewel at Buangkok
Tembusu Kovan
Whitley Residences
Reading this information So i am happy to exhibit that I have a very excellent uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed.midsummer
The condo’s facilities provide full family entertainment needs for your family and loved ones. Indulge in a serene and tranquil lifestyle right in the heart of Bartley.
Tai Keng court Condo
The main reason you want to get an education is to live a good life. To live a good life, you must be able to make enough money so you will be able pay all of your bills and keep your head above water. Any education beyond high school is recommended. Whatever level of education that you can attain, you owe it to yourself to pursue it and achieve it. Whether it is a one-year certificate program, 2-year college degree, 4-year college degree or advance degrees, you must pursue your education beyond high school to live a good life.
bobcat colombia
If you are looking for the perfect jewelry. you may want to consider designer jewelry. SilverSpringDesignz offers chainmaille jewelry in Niobium, Bright Aluminum and Anodized Aluminum. Click on the following links to view jewelry. designer jewelry
No wonder why knowledge is distributed by the most leading to thoughts.
Medical Receptionist Training Melbourne
I really like it. After reading your post, I got a lot of useful information. Thanks for sharing this post.
http://guocolandtp180.org
watch tp180
You are mailing awesome articles. You’re writing fashion throughout awesome and make good expertise. This great article on this site is incredibly IP in addition to proficient set up these content articles
Excellent blog right here! Also your site a lot up very fast! What web host are you the use. dental in singapore
I have been getting a lot of useful and informative material in your website. fibre optic broadband
this is great site we love to join this but if you want free mine craft code please visit our site
minecraft gift code
“We do see a reduce, but it’s not large,” says Monto. “And part of that can be included by a modify in age of wedding.” The analysis engaged information on More Bonuses essaythinker.com nearly 2,000 people from the Typical Public Study, a nationwide associate survey that requests a variety of concerns and has been performed since 1972.
It is useful and informative. Tri Mountain Performance Your insight in this matter is great.
Once you have your facial equipment, tools, and products ready, you can begin your at-home skincare treatment. Dim the lights, play some soft music, and follow these five steps to a self-facial. Enjoy! clarisonic reviews
Hurrah! Finally I got a website from where I be able to truly obtain helpful facts regarding my study and knowledge.
Buy backlinks
high pagerank backlinks
I am really like it very much for the interesting info in this blog that to this website is providing the wonderful info in this blog that to utilize the great technology in this blog. buy quality backlink
pr5 backlink
Imagine being able to get your own authority blog up and running in just a few clicks of a mouse? Well, with empower network you can, furthermore, you can also earn residual ongoing commission for selling the products they have on offer. Click for more information. click for more
Empower network is a very effective program when it comes to educating people about internet marketing. They highlight tips and strategies on how to improve internet marketing methods, developing other marketing methods and establishing the proper links with the proper websites. empower networking
When you are shopping for the latest technology trends in netbooks, the thing that will be on your mind is what it can do for your personal and business life, not how pretty it looks.
House repossession is a hot topic in the last few years. Avoid Repossession Today has been formed to help people deal with the fears of repossessions, we work alongside a renowned solicitor with over 20 years experience and success in repossession cases. This allows us to ensure you are getting the best possible help and advice. repossession
You might post on the templates for the blog. You should reveal it’s extraordinary. Your blog research might grow your pocket book Vakantie
I have express all the comments and suggestions posted by the visitors for this article are very fine,We will wait for your next article soonly. Zonvakantie
I am certain that there are many more pleasurable opportunities ahead for individuals who look into your blog and hope you can share more. Wintersport
I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post Vliegvakantie
If you are regularly running into the “Minecraft Out of Memory” error then we’re here to help you. Whenever possible, we try to update the materials every day. On the game Minecraft can talk for hours, the main point of the game Minecraft is that the whole world is made of cubes, and you are free to build whatever your heart desires to infinity. http://gameminecraft.ru
Lush Acres Executive Condominium (EC), an exciting new executive condo in Seng Kang West Way is set to launch within the 3rd Quater of 2013. Its strategic location between Yio Chu Kang Road and Fernvale Lane puts it in the radius with convenience access to newly operate Greenwich V Mall across the road as well as the future upcoming mall next to Fernvale LRT. view more
Are you looking to buy a GoPro action camera but not sure where to look to get the best deal? Visit here you can buy the right GoPro camera. There are a range of different models Buy GoPro
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks!
organic pest control
japanese mini truck parts
I am really like it very much for the interesting info in this blog that to this website is providing the wonderful info in this blog that to utilize the great technology in this blog.
Online Ordering System
replacement kitchen doors
I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
Project Management Software
This is definitely one of the better blogs I have read. You are so insightful, have so much real stuff to bring to the table. free movies online
Most useful and creative work from you and I am totally admit that. x men jacket
You have a very inspiring way of exploring and sharing your thoughts. It is very uncommon nowadays, lots of sites and blogs having copy pasted or rewritten info. But here, no doubt, info is original and very well structured. Keep it up. Agencia de Publicidad
Estudiar en el Extranjero
deca durabolin kaufen
anabolika steroide kaufen
Students and their parents are starting to wise up to the game, and the amount of student loan debt they think appropriate is plummeting. For example, in 2012 only 18% of people felt $20,000 in college and other cases debt was too much.but students do not think about that. psn codes free every student must think for.
We are a family-owned business that’s built its reputation on providing quality garage doors, reliable service, and professional workmanship.
garage door company Los Angeles
Hudson made his acting debut with a small part in the 1948 Warner Bros. film Fighter Squadron, and took 38 takes to successfully deliver his only line in the film.https://www.rebelmouse.com/thegirlfriendactivationsystem
I am really like it very much for the interesting info in this blog that to this website is providing the wonderful info in this blog that to utilize the great technology in this blog.http://powertripbev.com/a-synopsis-on-buying-real-instagram-followers/
Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people.solar panel reviews