How we, as a nation, find bounty and beauty in the future depends upon how we react to two trends emerging from the recent difficult period in American urbanism. The first of these trends is the increasing lack of affordability in mainstream urban America, with the costs of maintaining a middle-class lifestyle at a level where distinct have/have-not lines are now drawn. The second is the increasing authoritarianism in mainstream urban America, where decisions about how our cities function are guided by a new array of authority figures that represent the common good. Both trends point to a disempowerment of a vast section of the American population.
Our loss of housing affordability is an insidious development that will continue to eat away at the urban triumphalism that marked the beginning of this century. Generation Xers, seniors on fixed incomes and the struggling middle class will have much in common during the coming decade, with fewer and fewer housing solutions designed for them. If half of our consumer goods are purchased by the top ten percent, then the rest of us are increasingly irrelevant in terms of goods, and services, as well as in housing,
Affordability on Main Street was once a concern of Wall Street. It was broadly known as Fordism, from the days when Henry Ford paid decent wages so that his workers could afford his new product, the car. Today, with Main Street on its knees, Fordism is dead and Wall Street turns more and more to itself, and to large, multinational conglomerates for profits. Volume generated by the middle class comes from a few companies like Apple, and, as the class shrinks, psychological distance between the haves and have-nots widens the gap, especially for those with memories of the material wealth they had in earlier days.
Solutions to the affordability gap in the urban realm are conspicuous by their absence. Desirable addresses, decent houses, and access to amenities are now the province of relatively few, who are serviced by those on the outside, commuting into town from less hip and trendy places. New residential housing, driven by the Wall Street investment community, is geared towards the market-rate. The linkage between mass transit and affordable housing has been deftly snipped apart by the investment community, where the topic of affordable housing generates a yawn.
Solutions? We might do well to investigate anti-urban trends, where peripheral and rural communities are stable and growing, and look at how these communities cope. Housing solutions like prefabricated units (think trailer parks, America’s answer to the favela) might be studied.
Non-affordability, as a trend, is strongly linked to a co-evolutionary partner that is driving a wedge between the haves and have-nots: an authority figure which has become a new interlocutor in of the urban conversation, a sort of urban do-gooder to save us from ourselves, pushing more requirements and accepting fewer improvisations. Affordable housing has less to do with the square footage that is in that space, and more to do with the ingredients found within the square footage.
The gloved hand of quasi-government authority has come to rest upon our cities with an increasingly tight grip, in the name of the green lobby or in the name of the traditional town.
Cities underwent rapid change in the fifties and sixties due to the car, and subsequently parking garages, commercial strips, suburbs and highway overpasses sprouted. All these developments facilitated growth and expansion. Americans were remarkably unsentimental about their historic urban fabric, and notably experimental about innovative technological solutions to remove obstacles to this growth.
Today, our confidence is shaken. The rise of authorities to dictate urban form signals that the era of innovation and improvisation is over, and that American cities are entering a new era of more rigid control of what gets built. The authority, in the form of a Master Plan, treats the city as if it were a vast, private land holding, and its citizens as if they were animals in a forest that was about to be developed.
Master Plans have already been passed in Denver, Philadelphia, and Miami, and are on the boards for other cities in 2013. When a developer Master-Plans his land, he relies upon a Master to create the vision for the land, and this Master – credentialed, experienced, and hopefully talented – sets out the form of the future construction. The Master may have a passing interest in the voices from the land itself – biologists who count endangered species, for example – but the overarching form comes out of his mind, and the developer then implements the plan.
When the same process is used upon a living, dynamic city, the results vary. Future citizens, bound by the edicts of this Master Plan, may submit to the Master’s vision, or, they may chafe at its restrictions. These Master Plans are formulated with great citizen input and collaboration until the time at which they are set. After that, they are to be obeyed. The plans create a physical model, or form; they are like a glove into which the city must fit its future hand.
Master Plans attempt to take all possibilities into account, while creating ‘perfect’ rules by which the city can grow. Physical order, it is hoped, will lead to social order, as buildings once again behave like they did before the car. Should the future evolve as the Master predicts, the glove will fit the grown-up hand However, the future is notoriously difficult to predict.
The new regulatory regime has become fashionable as citizens, sickened by the dirt and ugliness of our cities, seek an authority to keep us from temptation. As such, Master Plans arise from a noble intent not unlike the one held by city planners at the turn of the 20th century: to improve urban hygiene. And they may be correct in thinking that emulating urban form as it was before the car might just bring walkability back into fashion once again.
The future, however, is ephemeral and dynamic, not static like a Master Plan, and may become frustrating to the Master Planners who have created elaborate blueprints for our nation’s cities. America’s fluid economic situation is giving rise to in-home workplaces, negating the need for traditional office space. It is giving rise to in-home manufacturing, reducing the size and complexity of factories. Warehouses, in today’s era of just-in-time-delivery, are being converted into other uses. And finally, Master Plans all seem to reminisce about Main Streets with lovely, tree-lined rows of shops under apartment (parking would be safely tucked in the back). These shops, renting for top dollar, stand empty today, made even more remote from reality with the advent of online retail.
In short, Master Plans that rigidly enforce an urban form of yesteryear may become next year’s white elephants. Cities bearing these master plans may find themselves with a regulatory burden that is reducing their desirability as places to live and work. Following these cities specifically, learning of their successes and failures, and analyzing how Master Plans are working will tell us a lot about the future.
As affordability is reduced and regulation increases, American cities could soon evolve into forms that are quite different from those of our past. And as confidence in the future fades, our cities take increasing comfort in the past, fossilizing our urban form as the Romans once did. For those underneath the affordability curve, improvisation and innovation will still continue, and insight into both of these emerging trends will yield a new sense of direction for the places where we live and work.
Richard Reep is an architect and artist who lives in Winter Park, Florida. His practice has centered around hospitality-driven mixed use, and he has contributed in various capacities to urban mixed-use projects, both nationally and internationally, for the last 25 years.
Flickr photo by alesh houdek: A walled and gated Miami home.
Comments
41 responses to “Urban Housing: A Master Plan for the Few”
Great expression of my experience in ‘paradise’ – Palm Beach County, Florida. I just left that over-regulated, over-priced and over-taxed ‘Paradise’ because of the planners’ belief they have THE answer to urban and suburban problems. In the 20 years I was there, the Zoning Ordinance increased from 400 pages to over 1000 pages. The planners must carry it to every meeting, because it’s impossible to know what the rules are. They would point to the ‘overlay’ districts as their answer to ‘perfect’ rules to grow by. Unfortunately, they just don’t get IT.
Jon
This needs a lot of determination towards positive planing and administration. However, plan made but it failed to manage the things as per expectations then it would be worst nightmare. So, before pointing fingers to anywhere, we need to acquire quite significant strategies and implementations in terms of employment, literacy and industrialization.free load boards
It is really a good help to all students and teachers. Thank you so much for a great descriptive essay topics this morning.
I can see you are very competent about what you write. I will be looking for jogos online
Well, they can plan it. But they don’t build it, so nothing will be built except for a little expensive stuff for the 1%. Those who want to build things will go to places with no plans. Its very simple.
That’s why cities like Chicago have 250,000 fewer people then it did ten years ago. And why Houston grows like crazy.
I think you push the “authoritarian” angle a bit too much in this article. Yes, planning and zoning is becoming much more ubiquitous and often times stricter in its regulations, but the public process that goes into such regulations and master plans is far more open and robust than anything a Robert Moses dealt with when building freeways in NYC. Planning professionals are implementing public policy only after it has been endorsed in numerous public venues and discussions and only after such authority has been granted by state legislatures made up of elected officials.
More to the point with master plans, at least in the state I’m from, such documents hardly have the legal weight of determinism you imply in your article. Master plans and growth policies are designed as a community vision; a document that embodies “what we want to see happen if given the right circumstances” much more than a spirit of central planning with the attitude of “we will build this, period.”
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information ? It is extremely helpful for me.
—
corsage plus-size dresses cocktail dresses flower girl dresses mother of the bride dresses quotes about life
Governor Rick Scott had urged repeal as a part of his program to create 700,000 new jobs in seven years in Florida. Economic research in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and the United States has associated slower economic growth with growth management programs.
buy youtube views
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has custom papers inspired me to start my own Blog..
I can see you are very competent about what you write. I will be looking for backlinks
In addition to learning how to tackle a broad spectrum of HPC challenges in disciplines such as material sciences, quantum chromo dynamics, plasma physics, life sciences, astro sciences and climate research primeiro
Data is not readily available for a number of urban and provincial level freeways in China that are not a part diy livery of the National Trunk Highway System.
I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion Telexfree
Also, please be sure to check out the three new articles that just launched on my new site for web developers: FlippinAwesome.org and roupas para revenda
Bloggou diversions incorporated diffuse images, wild images, unlimited rotations and reward adjusts. The aforementioned spaces quite electrified the players when they
Notes about observations, test results, diagnostic findings dhea 25mg
prescriptions and medical procedures. Not to mention the thousands of lines of ultrasound suplementos
Involved in equity for marginalized students, especially African American and superior paper Latina/Latino students.
Affordable housing has less to do with the square footage that is in that space, and more to do picture frames with the ingredients found within the square footage.
It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing. Mc Linsen
Wonderful post i must say. It touches a lot of urgent issues of our society. It is impossible to be uninvolved to these challenges. facebook search
If half of our consumer goods are purchased by the top ten percent, then the rest of us are increasingly irrelevant in terms of goods, and services, as well as in housing… cell phone spy software
cell phone listening
Scratch – makers of awesome, design-focused Nail wraps. New artwork by your favorite designers, nail artists & illustrators monthly! Nail wraps
This has fed through into popular culture, with student loan debt relief being part of the grab bag of demands made by the various “Occupy” movements. When you graduate from college with huge, non-dischargeable debts, and you can’t find a job, particularly in your chosen field, you no doubt complain loudly about this to your friends. http://www.acrylicbox.net/
The previous board had been spent on the following Portland style growth management policies, including the enforcement of a variant of the urban growth boundary. The new board exhibited more liberal attitudes toward residential development, and the housing bubble did not produce the extent of housing affordability in the Twin Cities that occurred in growth management areas such as Portland, California and Florida. Customized Fat Loss Review
I infer I haven’t interpreted specified incomparable physical anywhere added online.
that web
You made some good points there. The spirit of sharing is really impressive, and I want to share this article to my friends! . http://dreaminteriorsdesigns.com/
cool website buddy I am gona suggest this to all my list of contacts.
Blinder laser jammer store
Will the winners be emailed or something? Also for the Tweeting thing, does there need to be a certain hash tag, or does @HeroAcademy work just fine? favors for engagement parties
What a nice urban house picture which is very exciting. I am thinking about the urban housing. I will come t you to know more about the urban housing. Thanks a lot mate.
Pima College
Your computer is rattling instructive and your articles are wonderful.
Find Out More
Thanks for sharing this article, great way of bring this topic to discussion
hajj packages
The trees take measures to limit the loss of water through their leaves. create your own anime character
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks! Manual Directory Submission
Buy backlinks
high pagerank backlinks
Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and will look forward for additional updates. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips. manual directory submission
I’m glad Yahoo pointed me to it. I was able to get the know-how I was searching so badly for days now.free movies online
I trust this article. It was incredibly insightful and educated me with some information that I did so not understand before. I will be sure to check out the other articles on your own site and tell other people about any of it. I’ll certainly be time for read your other pieces.Florist Website Design
very cool, this seeming Castle graiskull, kkk
That’s good, all human being deserve decent housing, education, saneamente basic and dignity.
Sincerely AutoSurf.
Meet and greet car parking Birmingham
cheap car parking Birmingham
I am so impressed to read your content. I am looking forward for the next valuable and informative concept in your blog.
mio m3