As the country’s largest and densest metropolis, New York City has been able to offer a level of public transit service that most other cities can only dream about. Commuting to Downtown or Midtown Manhattan has been—and still is to a large degree—a remarkably easy affair for hundreds of thousands of residents, whose travel options include commuter train, subway, ferry and bus. However, like a lot of older American cities, New York has changed dramatically since most of those services were put into place, and more and more residents, particularly among lower-income workers, no longer travel to Manhattan for work.
Census data show that between 1990 and 2008 the number of residents who traveled to work in their own borough or a neighboring borough or county increased much faster than the number who made the more traditional commute to Manhattan. For instance, the number of Bronx residents who traveled to Queens or Westchester County for work increased by 38 percent, and the number who traveled inside the borough jumped by 25 percent, while the number commuting to Manhattan increased by only 13 percent in the same period.
The discrepancies on Staten Island are even starker: During the same period, the number of Staten Island residents traveling to work inside their own borough increased by 32 percent, and those going to Brooklyn or New Jersey increased by 22 percent, while the number heading into Manhattan barely changed at all—a four percent increase in those 18 years. Although not as dramatic, Brooklyn and Queens both saw significant gains in non-traditional commutes as well. In fact, the number of Brooklyn residents traveling to Queens grew by 32 percent, compared to a 13 percent increase in the number going to Manhattan. In 2008 despite being a notoriously difficult trip for public transit riders, nearly 160,000 people crossed the Brooklyn/Queens border for work everyday.
One big reason for this shift in commuter patterns is New York’s changing economic landscape. For decades Manhattan has been steadily losing its share of jobs to the other four boroughs, but over the last ten years that process has sped up considerably. From 2000 to 2009, New York City lost a net 41,833 jobs, but that was because of the huge concentration of losses in Manhattan during 2008 (over 100,000 in that single year). Every other borough saw a net increase in jobs during that period. Queens saw 2.4 percent growth, Staten Island 4.6 percent growth and the Bronx and Brooklyn 7.7 and 7.9 percent growth, respectively.
It won’t come as surprise to those who have been paying close attention to the economy that robust job gains in the health care and education sectors are what lie behind sustained growth in the outer boroughs. Between 2000 and 2009, New York City gained nearly 120,000 jobs in those two sectors alone. And although Midtown Manhattan has several prominent hospitals and universities, collectively, the hundreds of hospitals, nursing homes, community health clinics, colleges and professional schools in the other four boroughs—from Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx and SUNY Downstate Medical Center in Brooklyn to Queensborough Community College in Bayside—accounted for the lion’s share of jobs in those sectors.
New York City’s transit system wasn’t designed for commuter trips to jobs within and between boroughs outside of Manhattan, and as a result the city’s median commute times have been rising steadily for decades. According to American Community Survey data released last December, New York’s four outer boroughs all have median commute times that are north of 40 minutes, which puts them among the longest in the country. And among public transit riders they are significantly longer, ranging from 52 minutes each way in Brooklyn to a barely comprehensible 69 minutes each way in Staten Island.
In our study, we interviewed a number of outer borough employers who felt that a lack of dependable rapid transit service has exacted a toll on their businesses. A lack of transit effectively shrinks their labor pool, they said, and causes more turnover as disgruntled employees decide to leave rather than suffer through two hour commutes every day. The chief operating officer at SUNY Downstate Medical Center in East Flatbush Brooklyn even said that it could cause the hospital to rethink its plans for expansion. “I’ve been here 24 years,” he said, “and I still haven’t seen any improvements in mass transit.”
New York’s biggest investments in transit are still almost entirely focused on Manhattan commuters. Tens of billions of dollars are being invested in what amounts to an extension of the Q train along Second Avenue, a new Long Island Railroad tunnel to Grand Central, a one stop extension of the number 7 train on the west side, and a Santiago Calatrava-designed Fulton Street Station in lower Manhattan. A new Moynihan Station on 34th Street is apparently next on the agenda. These projects may spawn billions more in lucrative real estate deals, but they don’t reflect the city’s true economic geography.
A lack of transit investments in the outer boroughs might be understandable if these new outer borough jobs were spread out evenly over a large territory, but a huge percentage are located in relatively dense clusters. Over 20,000 commuters descend on the SUNY Downstate and Kings County Medical Campuses — right across the street from each other —every morning, for example. But very little has been done to facilitate commutes to that area, and many employees and patients depend on a dizzying array of livery cabs and dollar vans to get them where they’re going. Similarly, JFK airport in Queens is home to over 55,000 jobs; Hunts Point in the Bronx 20,000; the Sunset Park waterfront in Brooklyn 32,000, and so on.
Making much needed investments in service and upgrades to the bus system may not be as sexy as a new train terminal in Midtown. But if New York is going to sustain job growth and retain a truly world-class transit system, then it will have to start looking beyond Manhattan and invest in solutions that make commutes to job centers in the outer boroughs easier for residents.
David Giles is a research associate at the Center for an Urban Future, a Manhattan-based think tank. He is the author of Behind the Curb, a Center for an Urban Future report about the gaps in transit service in the four boroughs of New York City outside of Manhattan, from which this article was adapted. For the whole report, please visit BehindtheCurb or www.nycfuture.org.
Photo: The Brooklyn Bridge by S J Pinkey
Comments
74 responses to “NY Borough to Borough Commute? Fuhgeddaboudit”
Bravo, Mr. Giles. While the Second Ave. subway will at least relieve overcrowding on the Lexington Ave. line (it would be more helpful if it took advantage of underutilized rail capacity and tied Co-Op City in the Bronx to the subway system, but that’s asking for too much creativity), the Fulton Street “Transit Center” is a complete waste of billions and an example of myopic and elitist Manhattan-ism. Despite the hoopla, the Fulton Street complex is not now, never was and never will be a transit center. It’s merely the place where several subway lines in crowded Lower Manhattan cross and where PATH trains terminate. True, the subway stations — original IRT, BMT and IND stops crammed under narrow streets — were in need of refurbishing. But Fulton Street is not a terminal point for any major rail line (PATH is a subway linking Newark, Jersey City and Hoboken to Manhattan, not a multi-line suburban rail system) and is more like Union Square or Atlantic Ave. in Brooklyn — where several subway lines converge — than it is like Penn Station or Grand Central. The ridiculously expensive Calatrava extravaganza will attract not one more person or one more business to Lower Manhattan; it will merely make transferring from the A to the 4 or the J a little less horrible (the subway platforms themselves can’t be widened because there’s no room). Of course, since nothing has been spent to expand subway service in outer Brooklyn or Queens over the last 50 or so years, the poor schleppers transferring from a jam-packed 4 to a crammed A train so they can go to jobs in midtown, will still feel like sardines. And since Lower Manhattan still lacks direct LIRR or Jersey Transit access which would attract business, these subway riders are likely never to see the soaring Fulton Street subway entrance that epitomizes the hubris of Manhattan mandarins.
First held in 1943, the event was designed to attract attention away from the French fashion during World War II, when fashion industry insiders were unable to travel to Paris to see French fashion shows.
fresh Louisiana crawfish delivered Houston
NYC like anywhere else in the US has found that jobs have dispersed throughout the whole region. I think many (namely the elite of the city) haven’t realized or ignore that Manhattan isn’t the only employment center anymore. So the majority of the effort goes to that one place.
Since most of the outer borough jobs are of the unsexy lower and middle class variety rather then the more sexy upper middle and upper class jobs, the leadership does little to improve the transportation to these places.
Most places solve these outer jobs transportation problems by driving to them, due to no transit or so little it doesn’t matter much. That doesn’t work as well in NYC due to the higher densities, geography and the lower incomes (most “poor” of most cities do have cars but due to NYC high cost of living, not so much).
NYC is a wonderful place to live if you are wealthy or at least upper middle class. If you are lower on the scale, not so much. NYC is increasingly more and more unlivable (expensive, crowded, inconvenient, lousy schools). If NYC wants to continue to be the place to be, it is important to make the city more livable to more of its residents, not just it’s rich and wealthy. Some day, when there are only the rich, (and the very poor) the quality of life will be terrible even for the rich. The city needs a large middle class and the city does all it can to drive them out. That has to stop.
A fixed and prettied up Manhattan may make the city look more livable, but it really does little for the outer boroughs where most people actually live. A healthy downtown is a start to a revitalized city but its only the first step. Its a problem of many big cities not just NYC.
And since Lower Manhattan still lacks direct LIRR or Jersey Transit access which would attract business, these subway riders are likely never to see the soaring Fulton Street subway entrance that epitomizes the hubris of Manhattan mandarins.marketing web
Lucky me I discovered your website by accident, and I’m shocked why this coincidence didn’t took place earlier! I bookmarked it.Forest Service’s land use planning rules along with my current take on the draft rules and some suggestions for public comments. I am updating these ideas according to article critique help
regularly and I welcome your feedback.
Black Box Network Services is a world leader in communications and infrastructure products and solutions for today’s leading enterprises.
Chicago Shoretel
Always bear in mind that your own resolution to succeed is more important than any other.
Company Register
I’ve failed over and over and over again in my life and that is why I succeed.
bucks party idea
The practice of geography is by its nature a ticklish, paradoxical enterprise. It is at once the study of objects and of subjects, of things and of behaviors, of the world around us as a phenomenon producing human activity and produced by it.
case study help
Every other borough saw a net increase in jobs during that period. Queens saw 2.4 percent growth, Staten Island 4.6 percent growth and the Bronx and Brooklyn 7.7 and 7.9 percent growth, respectively.bilderberg
And since Lower Manhattan still lacks direct LIRR or Jersey Transit access which would attract business, these subway riders are likely never to see the soaring Fulton Street subway entrance that epitomizes the hubris of Manhattan mandarins.Boise Custom Home Builder
And among public transit riders they are significantly longer, ranging from 52 minutes each way in Brooklyn to a barely comprehensible 69 minutes each way in Staten Island. free cell phone spy software
cell phone spyware
thanks for the information about the vehicle you are discussing, because I love driving and I do not know anything about the vehicle when my vehicle was damaged …
Dog Life Jacket
I am very interested in what you write. I think I can understand a lot for me to learn better.
Sarong
Formal education will make you a living; self-education will make you a fortune.
bucks party ideas
Company Search
For the past 33 years, I have looked in the mirror every morning and asked myself: ‘If today were the last day of my life, would I want to do what I am about to do today?’ And whenever the answer has been ‘No’ for too many days in a row, I know I need to change something.
C’est vraiment agréable d’entendre votre discussion sur le sujet spécifique ici. Moi aussi, je suis d’accord avec vos points ici. garder l’affichage bons blogs. Mais je veux savoir plus de nouvelles à propos de Hollywood et pour cela demander votre aide.Alarme piscine homologuée
Alarme piscine homologuéeC’est vraiment agréable d’entendre votre discussion sur le sujet spécifique ici. Moi aussi, je suis d’accord avec vos points ici. garder l’affichage bons blogs. Mais je veux savoir plus de nouvelles à propos de Hollywood et pour cela demander votre aide.
Thanks for all the comments. Be on the look out, I plan on doing more stories like this.
Wonderful article about a wonderful artform. Saw this video on fb, but I didn’t know the story.Thanks
Juniper
his is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article! That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this!
Durkl Snapbacks
Always bear in mind that your own resolution to succeed is more important than any other.
good college application essays
That is why it is better that you should relevant research before writing. You will be able to write better post this waystatistics with stata
Although not as dramatic, Brooklyn and Queens both saw significant gains in non-traditional commutes as well. In fact, the number of Brooklyn residents traveling to Queens grew by 32 percent, compared to a 13 percent increase in the number going to Manhattan.
designer iphone 4 case
Thanks for the inspirational nudge. I tend an unloved community pocket garden that just may get enough sun to become a wee herb garden. At least I hope so…basil, parsley, tarragon, chives, rosemary, sage, and mint have already been planted.Ontra
I completely agree with you. Great posting love this way, I have no point to raise in against of what you have said I think you explain the whole situation very well.Thanks.aftec concrete fence.
Your work is going to fill a large part of your life, and the only way to be truly satisfied is to do what you believe is great work. And the only way to do great work is to love what you do. If you haven’t found it yet, keep looking. Don’t settle. As with all matters of the heart, you’ll know when you find it.
case study for mba
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.
buy dofollow backlink
Take up one idea. Make that one idea your life – think of it, dream of it, live on that idea. Let the brain, muscles, nerves, every part of your body, be full of that idea, and just leave every other idea alone. This is the way to success.
Forex Broker Review
Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.
fxopen
A new Moynihan Station on 34th Street is apparently next on the agenda. These projects may spawn billions more in lucrative real estate deals, but they don’t reflect the city’s true economic geography. VPN service
The post is absolutely fantastic. It is really great piece of data.
I like the way you written this content. Pleasure thanks for the share and stuff. payment processing
Breathtaking! To articulate the exactness this is a finicky post concerning this topic. I got a pure solution from here. Also I can refer to you all hwsolvers.com/physics_homework here to get educational helps. Nevertheless will wait for more posts from the blogger. Thanks a lot…….
Always be yourself, express yourself, have faith in yourself, do not go out and look for a successfull personality and duplicate it.
buy a research paper
Vous pouvez commenter la navigation sur le blog. Vous pouvez attribuer c’est mieux notés. Votre analyse de blog pourrait accroître vos amis. Alarme piscine homologuée
My favorite things in life don’t cost any money. It’s really clear that the most precious resource we all have is time.
VPN service
If truth be told awe-inspiring toil with the blog. I do akin to your durable employment and will hang around for more post from you as post gave me satisfaction and gives some helps to do same work right here. Thanks a lot…………………………
business valuation in Dallas
Tens of billions of dollars are being invested in what amounts to an extension of the Q train along Second Avenue, a new Long Island Railroad tunnel to Grand Central, a one stop extension of the number 7 train on the west side, and a Santiago Calatrava-designed Fulton Street Station in lower Manhattan.
buy a research paper
I wanted to thank your entire family for the awesome digest!! While i rather worthy each and every single spot of this but i at any time saved to fav to adhere to hot points you content.website development
Take up one idea. Make that one idea your life – think of it, dream of it, live on that idea. Let the brain, muscles, nerves, every part of your body, be full of that idea, and just leave every other idea alone. This is the way to success.
high speed VPN service
Most people have no concept of how an automatic transmission works, yet they know how to drive a car. You don’t have to study physics to understand the laws of motion to drive a car. You don’t have to understand any of this stuff to use Macintosh.
business topics
When possible, stand up for the underdog and let your child see you doing it. Empowerment means standing up for yourself, so if there is a situation in your life that requires you to do this, include your child in the discussion about it as much as is appropriate. Thanks.
Regards,
aaancient regular font
Excellent post.The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post.Ontra Studios Utah SEO.
Bottom line is, I didn’t return to Apple to make a fortune. I’ve been very lucky in my life and already have one. When I was 25, my net worth was $100 million or so. I decided then that I wasn’t going to let it ruin my life. There’s no way you could ever spend it all, and I don’t view wealth as something that validates my intelligence.
psychology essay topics
Always be yourself, express yourself, have faith in yourself, do not go out and look for a successfull personality and duplicate it.
female celebrities photos
What a tremendous post that I even have ever come back through. It provides the data that i used to be very looking for the past week and that i am very glad with this post. would like a lot of like this. Thank youSterling Silver Rings
Take up one idea. Make that one idea your life – think of it, dream of it, live on that idea. Let the brain, muscles, nerves, every part of your body, be full of that idea, and just leave every other idea alone. This is the way to success.
Thai Lottery
The most important single ingredient in the formula of success is knowing how to get along with people.
write my thesis
A lot of people in our industry haven’t had very diverse experiences. So they don’t have enough dots to connect, and they end up with very linear solutions without a broad perspective on the problem. The broader one’s understanding of the human experience, the better design we will have.
AC Repair Las Vegas
Oh! Superb post. Really this site is incredibly ready to lend a hand for all concerning this. I got hardly any important helps from here and very recommended it. Definitely I will be familiar with my relatives and relevant competitors concerning this blog and will wait for more. Thanks a lot…….
click here
Always bear in mind that your own resolution to succeed is more important than any other.
lavage de vitres montreal
SEO works as magical formula and it is not easy to understand. Mostly Search Engine Optimization contains six parts Research for keywords,content writing article creation submission to the web, bookmarking on social sites, video marketing and submission of RSS to the webs.
In truth breathtaking job with the blog. I do approximating your stiff exertion and will hang around for more post from you as post gave me delight and gives some helps to do same work right here. Thanks a lot…………………………
Business valuation firms in New Jersey
This is probably one of the best mentions of this topic I’ve seen in quite a while. It’s obvious that your knowledge of the subject is deep and this made for a very interesting read.< newstylecondensed bold fonts
Use a small magnet or compass to help find the nails, because these same quality finishers do not leave unsightly nail holes behind for you to find. They are filled in with finishing putty for an invisible finish. Thanks.
Regards,
ethical search engine optimization
Article is a most popular in the world. I am working in article and enjoy it very much. I hope that in most of the time I will do it Innentueren
This blog has definitely changed my perspective on this subject. There’s no way I would’ve thought about it this way if I hadn’t come across your blog. All I was doing was cruising the web and I found your blog and all of a sudden my views have changed.
here
If truth be told prosperous content and exceedingly valuable information. I got it my result over here. I exceedingly urge his/her workings with the positive informative information. Thanks a lot………..
essay online
I didn’t see it then, but it turned out that getting fired from Apple was the best thing that could have ever happened to me. The heaviness of being successful was replaced by the lightness of being a beginner again, less sure about everything. It freed me to enter one of the most creative periods of my life.
avocat a laval
I don’t think it’s good that Apple’s perceived as different. I think it’s important that Apple’s perceived as *much better*. If being different is essential to doing that, then we have to do that, but if we can be much better without being different, that’d be fine with me. I want to be much better.
http://www.bestcustomwriting.com/topic-ideas/essay/art-class
We’re both busy and we both don’t have a lot of time to learn how to use a washing machine or to use a phone – you get one of the phones now and you’re never going to learn more than 5 per cent of the features. You’re never going to use more than 5 per cent, and, uh, it’s very complicated. So you end up using just 5 per cent. It’s insane: we all have busy lives, we have jobs and we have interests and some of us have children, everyone’s lives are just getting busier, not less busy, in this busy society. You just don’t have time to learn this stuff, and everything’s getting more complicated.
thai lottery
You reveal wonderful data. Create article beautiful as well as article writing stage is superb easily understand to be able to anyone that can read your article knowning that increase my knowledge.
Shop Karen Millen ireland
In reality prosperous content and extraordinarily functional information. I got it my elucidation from now. I vastly counsel his/her moving parts with the functional enlightening information. Thanks a lot………..
sun business valuations
Wonderful! Actually wealthy content and extremely helpful in sequence. I got it my answer from over here. I extremely advocate his/her mechanism with the helpful educational information. Thanks a lot………..
business appraisal Cincinnati
Always be yourself, express yourself, have faith in yourself, do not go out and look for a successfull personality and duplicate it.
Tucson Personal Trainer
In reality splendid occupation with the blog. I do in the vein of your rigid effort and will linger for more post from you as post gave me joy and gives some helps to do same work right here. Thanks a lot…………………………
Las Vegas
Thanks for the inspirational nudge. I tend an unloved community pocket garden that just may get enough sun to become a wee herb garden. At least I hope so…basil, parsley, tarragon, chives, rosemary, sage, and mint have already been planted. payment processing
That’s been one of my mantras – focus and simplicity. Simple can be harder than complex: You have to work hard to get your thinking clean to make it simple. But it’s worth it in the end because once you get there, you can move mountains.
VPN service benefits
I need to thank you for this great read!! I surely got a charge out of every single touch of it. I have got you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post… Read my post about South India Travel or Kerala Tour Package
Formal education will make you a living; self-education will make you a fortune.
cainsquotes.com
Your time is restricted, thus do not waste it living somebody else’s life. do not be treed by dogma – that resides with the results of different people’s thinking. do not let the noise of others’ opinions make noise your own inner voice. And most significant, have the spirit to follow your heart and intuition. about proofreading and editing services
Wow!I have visited several site over the past few days. Upon look the posts of each I do assume that this specific web site was the only real one UN agency had grabbed the apex of my interest.Well done. book of ra online
Everybody I know that has been to NY, always says it’s a dirty place, but whenever I see images of it, it always looks nice and clean, maybe it’s because they rarely show the neighborhoods, just the business district. – Uche’s Boxing Source
I have not been able to find such kind of information throughout the search engines and internet. It’s been fabelously informative to read your blog and i am going to suggest it to another fellow as well. credit card processing services
You want to know whether the project is making the changes to people’s lives that you want it to. You can’t know how well it’s working without evaluating. Like it or not, we are all subject to bias and, at best, only ever have a partial picture of what’s going on check plagiarism online for free. Evaluation helps us to get the big picture and combine different perspectives to understand the impact of a project.