For many mayors across the country, including New York City’s Michael Bloomberg, the recently announced results of the 2010 census were a downer. In a host of cities, the population turned out to be substantially lower than the U.S. Census Bureau had estimated for 2010—in New York’s case, by some 250,000 people. Bloomberg immediately called the decade’s meager 2.1 percent growth, less than one-quarter the national average, an “undercount.” Senator Charles Schumer blamed extraterrestrials, accusing the Census Bureau of “living on another planet.” The truth, though, is that the census is very much of this world. It just isn’t the world that mayors, the media, and most urban planners want to see.
Start with the fact that America continues to suburbanize. The country’s metropolitan areas have two major components: core cities (New York City, for example) and suburbs (such as Westchester County, Long Island, northern New Jersey, and even Pike County in Pennsylvania). During the 2000s, the census shows, just 8.6 percent of the population growth in metropolitan areas with more than a million people took place in the core cities; the rest took place in the suburbs. That 8.6 percent represents a decline from the 1990s, when the figure was 15.4 percent. The New York metropolitan area was no outlier: though it did better than the national average, with 29 percent of its growth taking place within New York City, that’s still a lot lower than the 46 percent that the center region saw in the 1990s.
This may be shocking to some. For years, academics, the media, and big-city developers have been suggesting that suburbs were dying and that people were flocking back to the cities that they had fled in the 1970s. The Obama administration has taken this as gospel. “We’ve reached the limits of suburban development,” Housing and Urban Development secretary Shaun Donovan opined in 2010. “People are beginning to vote with their feet and come back to the central cities.” Yet of the 51 metropolitan areas that have more than 1 million residents, only three—Boston, Providence, and Oklahoma City—saw their core cities grow faster than their suburbs. (And both Boston and Providence grew slowly; their suburbs just grew more slowly. Oklahoma City, meanwhile, built suburban-style residences on the plentiful undeveloped land within city limits.)
All this suburbanization means that the best unit for comparison may not be the core city but the metropolitan area, and the census shows clearly which metropolitan areas are growing and which are not. The top ten population gainers—growing by 20 percent, twice the national average or more—are the metropolitan areas surrounding Las Vegas, Raleigh, Austin, Charlotte, Riverside–San Bernardino, Orlando, Phoenix, Houston, San Antonio, and Atlanta. These areas are largely suburban in form. None developed the large, dense core cities that dominated America before the post–World War II suburban boom began. By contrast, many of the metropolitan areas that grew at rates half the national average or less—San Francisco, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Boston, New York—have core areas that are the old, dense variety. Planners and pundits may like density, but people, for the most part, continue to prefer more space.
If you do look at cities themselves, rather than at larger metropolitan areas, you’ll see that the census reveals three different categories. The most robust cities, with population growth over 15 percent for the decade—Raleigh, Austin, Charlotte, Las Vegas, Jacksonville, and Orlando—were located within the kind of metropolitan area that urbanists tend to dislike: highly suburbanized, dominated by single-family homes, and with few people using public transit. That’s partly because these cities developed along largely suburban lines by annexing undeveloped land and low-density areas. This has been the case in virtually all the fastest-growing cities. Raleigh has expanded its boundaries to become 12 times larger than it was in 1950; Charlotte and Orlando are nine times larger, and Jacksonville an astounding 25 times larger.
At the opposite end of the spectrum are core cities, mostly in the Midwest and Northeast and often land-constrained, that have continued to shrink. These include longtime disaster zones like Detroit and Cleveland as well as newer ones like Birmingham in the South. They include Pittsburgh, a city much praised for its livability but one that is aging rapidly and whose city government, based disproportionately on revenue from universities and nonprofits, is among the nation’s most fiscally strapped. They even include Chicago, which lost some 200,000 people during the 2000s, its population falling to the lowest level since the 1910 census. The reasons aren’t hard to identify: despite all the hype about Chicago’s recovery and the legacy of Mayor Richard M. Daley, the Windy City is among the most fiscally weak urban areas in the country, its schools are in terrible shape, and its economy is struggling.
Finally, there are cities that have grown, but not quickly. New York City’s population, for example, inched to a record high in the 2000s, but that growth was less than the national average. The population of Los Angeles grew a mere 97,000—the smallest increase since the 1890s. Many of the slow-growing cities (New York, San Francisco, and Boston, for example) suffer from high housing costs, which inhibit population growth. But they also host high-end industries—finance, technology, and business services—and enough well-paid workers in these industries to afford pricey housing and sustain a small rate of growth. The cities also attract already wealthy people from elsewhere.
The census provides information on a smaller level, too, telling us not just which cities have grown, but where the growth has taken place within cities. Often, it has been in and around the historic downtowns. This is a trend in many cities that otherwise differ starkly (New York, St. Louis, Chicago, Los Angeles), and it reflects a subtle shift in the role of the downtown. Rather than reasserting themselves as dominant job centers, downtowns are becoming residential and cultural—a change that H. G. Wells predicted when he wrote that by 2000, the center of London would be “essentially a bazaar, a great gallery of shops and places of concourse and rendezvous.” What may have been an office, industrial, or retail zone morphs into a gentrified locale attractive to the migratory global rich, to affluent young people, and to childless households.
This downtown recovery (which many cities subsidized heavily) was partly why so many urbanists and developers identified a broader back-to-the-city movement; but in reality, the phenomenon was usually limited to a relatively small population and a relatively small area. Since 1950, for example, St. Louis has lost a greater share of its population than any American city ever boasting 500,000 or more residents. The area from downtown to Central West End experienced strong growth during the 2000s, however, adding more people than Portland’s Pearl District, a favorite of urban planners. Yet this gain of 7,000 people was far from enough to offset the loss of 36,000 in the rest of St. Louis.
It’s also worth noting that in economic terms, downtowns are losing their hold. For example, though the residential population of Chicago’s Loop tripled to 20,000 in the past decade, that famed business district lost almost 65,000 jobs; its share of the metropolitan area’s employment also fell. Los Angeles’s downtown, whose population has likewise grown, lost roughly 200,000 jobs from 1995 to 2005. Manhattan is losing employment share to the other four boroughs, as it has been for decades; but as a recent report from the Center for an Urban Future reveals, the process accelerated over the last ten years. From 2000 to 2009, Manhattan lost a net 41,833 jobs, while other boroughs saw net increases. This employment dispersion is even more evident in the suburbs. Of commuters who live in the inner-ring suburbs (such as Yonkers and East Orange), 60 percent work in their home counties and only 14 percent in Manhattan. Of commuters from such outer-ring suburbs as Haverstraw and Morristown, 73 percent work in their home counties and 6 percent in Manhattan.
What, in the end, does the census tell us about America’s cities today? Certainly not that they’re dying, as they threatened to do in the 1950s, but equally certainly that they aren’t roaring back. Cities remain a successful niche product for a relatively small percentage of the population. Most people, though, even in the New York metropolitan area, continue to move toward the periphery rather than the core. That said, New York’s continuing growth over the past decade suggests that its recovery will likely prove durable. As for Senator Schumer’s “another planet” allegations, the census is simply confirming the fact that terrestrial Americans continue to disperse, both within and among metropolitan areas. So far, there’s little that planners, policy makers, and urban boosters can do about that.
This piece originally appeared in City Journal.
Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and is a distinguished presidential fellow in urban futures at Chapman University, and an adjunct fellow of the Legatum Institute in London. He is author of The City: A Global History
Wendell Cox is a Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris and the author of “War on the Dream: How Anti-Sprawl Policy Threatens the Quality of Life”
Photo by caruba
Comments
34 responses to “Cities and the Census: Cities Neither Booming Nor Withering”
A close reading of the results from the just released 2011 Community Preference Survey from National Association of Realtors provides further understanding of why suburbanization continues in USA.
These results — both top line and an interpretation — are at http://www.realtor.org/government_affairs/smart_growth/survey.
One quote: “Living in an area that is “away from it all” (53%, important) is appealing for more Americans than one that is “in the center of it all” (34%)”
The fact that our society wants to live “away from it all” is a good indicator of a failing society.
Some explanations/fixes
Americans work more and vacation less than other developed countries. Our desire to “get away from it all” when purchasing a home could mean that Americans are coupling their home and vacation time/money. If there was more respect for the working person and middle class, longer vacation times would be allowed, and peoples desire to “get away from it all” might not dominate that purchase preference.
Until the externalities of suburban/non-walkable development are internalized into the market and tax structure, Americans can afford to ignore each other and society. If and when the externalities are internalized, it will force Americans to live and work more closely together and solve our problems rather than leave them to the next generation.
text the romance back It’s been a few days since Michael Fiore announced the launch of the Claire Casey Capture His Heart And Make Him Love You Forever ebook and one thing is …
Pensions advice FREE Pension Review…Release CASH from your…Frozen Pension! CASH FROM FROZEN PENSION, 100% FREE ADVICE, NO HIDDEN COSTS, EXPERT FROZEN PENSION ADVISORS. Get your FREE frozen pension review – Get started today. Have a Pension? – Get a TAX Free CASH payment! Get £1000′s!! Get a CASH payment from your pension – No Hidden Fees or Hidden Costs + Free Review!
http://rebelmouse.com Grow Taller 4 Idiots Ebook: How To Grow Taller Using A Combination Of Extremely Effective Height Gain Exercises, Sneaky Appearance Tricks, And “Height Boosting Cocktails” This site is a leading resource for information about the Darwin Smith Grow Taller 4 Idiots PDF book and complete height increase system that teaches you how to grow taller naturally even if you’ve been cursed with bad genetics or stopped growing on your own years ago.
http://rebelmouse.com Banish My Bumps Ebook: How To Get Rid Of Keratosis Pilaris Using An All-Natural Remedy Right From Home. This site is a leading resource for information about the Angela Steinberg Banish My Bumps PDF book and keratosis pilaris treatment system that teaches you how to cure KP permanently and achieve clear, flawless skin step-by-step.
Several buses are available near Lush Acres EC along with shopping centers and restaurants. Lush Acres EC is also near Waterway Point, the shopping, dining and entertainment hub which is scheduled to open in 2 years time in Sengkang. Also, it is right beside Fernvale Link. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends are therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities near Lush Acres EC.
Lush Acres Location
rebelmouse.com Fat Loss Factor: Eat The Foods You Love And Still Get The Stunning Body You Deserve. This site is a leading resource for information about the Dr Charles Fat Loss Factor PDF book and weight loss system that teaches you how to burn fat to sculpt an incredible body while still enjoying many of the foods that are supposed to make you fat.
all belly pregnancy All-Belly Pregnancy Program: How To Eat And Exercise When Expecting To Stay Fit, Have A Strong, Healthy Baby, And Be One “Hot Mama”! This site is a leading resource for information about the Ryan Watson and Flavia Del Monte All Belly Pregnancy PDF book, diet manual, and exercises for pregnant women that help you carry your pregnancy weight with ease, prepare you for giving birth and beyond, and help you keep your baby healthy and happy inside the womb.
http://www.rebelmouse.com The Michael Fiore Text Your Ex Back 2.0 PDF and multimedia texting system is here! Read reviews, get download and purchase links, and learn about Michael Fiore text examples and techniques to get your ex back.
hidradenitis suppurativa cure Fast Hidradenitis Suppurativa Cure Ebook: Hidradenitis Suppurativa Home Remedies To Eliminate Flare Ups And Outbreaks And Keep Them From Ever Coming Back. This site is a leading resource for information about the Therese Wilson Fast Hidradenitis Suppurativa Cure PDF book and hidradenitis suppurativa treatment system that teaches you how to get rid of your unsightly and painful skin condition step-by-step using a simple, natural, and permanent method from home.
http://www.rebelmouse.com The Renegade Diet: Jason Ferruggia Reveals A Revolutionary Diet To Gain Muscle While Losing Fat Simultaneously OR The Renegade Diet: A Diet Plan That Breaks All The Rules To Burn Fat And Build Muscle Simultaneously …..
rebelmouse.com Venus Factor: John Barban Reveals A Breakthrough Tip For Controlling Weight Loss, Igniting Your Female Metabolism, And Helping You Drop Up To 3 Dress Sizes In As Little As One Week…Even If You’ve Been “Cursed” With Bad Genetics OR Venus Factor System: Get Your Sexy Confidence Back And Love Your Body
how to go down on a woman Lick By Lick: Michael Webb Reveals How To Go Down On A Girl, Stimulating Her To Orgasm And Making Her Beg For More OR Lick By Lick Ebook: How To Give Your Woman The Most Pleasurable Oral Experience Of Her Life…..
read jenny’s book on natural breast enlargement Boost Your Bust: Jenny Bolton Reveals How To Increase Your Breast Size By 2 Cups In As Little As 4-6 Weeks…Naturally And Without Surgery OR Boost Your Bust: Get The Sexy Curves That Drive Men Wild By Using The “Magic Formula” To Natural Breast Enlargement …
make her crave you Make Her Crave You Ebook: How To Attract Women You Currently Think You Don’t Have A “Shot In Hell” Of Sleeping With. This site is a leading resource for information about the Greg Hart and Slade Shaw Make Her Crave You PDF book and complete attraction guide that teaches you how to attract women you previously thought were “out of your league” using a simple, step-by-step series of “emotional addiction triggers” the television industry has already proven women can’t resist…
how to tell if a girl likes you more than a friend How To Tell If A Girl Likes You: Signs To Look For. If you’re wondering how to tell if a girl likes you, you’re definitely not alone. Guys face this dilemma every single day. One of the most frustrating things about dating women is finally building up the nerve to go up and talk ……
I really appreciate the info you showed there. Keep doing what you’re doing. Resources like the one you mentioned here is very useful. fönsterdörrar
information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that “The content of your post is awesome. cheap health insurance
imply wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply great and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the gratifying work. keep a man addicted
Incredible, your article is fairly remarkable. I have to state that from now your site will grow to be certainly one of my faves. Keeping it heading close friend click here
homepage Sea Horizon EC is also near elite schools such as Hai Sing Catholic School and Casuarina Primary School. Dunman Secondary School, Meridian Junior College and Tampines Junior College are also around in the area…
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can’t wait to read lots of your posts. the secret survey
I do not recogniѕе whο you might bе hоwever ԁefinіtеly. you are goіng to a ωеll-κnоwn bloggeг fοr thoѕе who aren’t already. Cheers! krankenversicherung
Your own making is merely astonishing and that i wish to read through superior quality material, I most certainly will be glad to lesezeichen your web blog and are avalable backside for more bootcamp Coogee Beach
The Seize His Coronary heart system also will come with Claire Casey’s Dump Radar worksheet which permits women of all ages to identify the cues any time a person is going to start off pulling absent and how to proceed to get back his passion, the person of the Goals checklist for choosing the ideal in the most effective, and Magnetically Entice Amazing Guys with British isles relationship mentor Matthew Hussey capture his heart discount.Seize His Coronary heart and Make Him Appreciate You Eternally is built don’t just for that one gal on the lookout for Mr. Correct, but with the female who now has her person and desires to make the magical connection of her goals. The class demonstrates you the way to determine, recognize and take away many of the invisible limitations that stand in between both you and your male.
Summary The Purely natural Vitiligo Treatment method Procedure provides a safer strategy to forever heal the pores and skin ailment vitiligo. Supplied the likely negative effects of regular treatment options, this process is usually a breath of clean air to therapeutic this awful pores and skin ailment get discount here. For anybody around that suffers from vitiligo, this method is definitely a must-have.
This system arrives within an simple to fully grasp digital structure. An e book. This has the primal burn off food stuff listing.Paleo Melt away fees 37 go to paleo burn site, that is a particularly very good offer for your product or service which will help you reduce substantial quantities of bodyweight In a very wholesome and risk-free way. I really suggest Paleo Burn up, as it is based upon a sustainable and scientifically tested means of body weight decline.
Not long ago we begun investigating pounds reduction plus more exclusively pounds decline and muscle mass creating for your woman human body. We find there are loads of weight loss plans and exercise routine plans to choose from go venus factor official site, but none of these concentration precisely using the way a women’s entire body is fashioned.There are lots of items that are created by adult males and so they will not choose in in any way the feminine variety, but fairly just lump them in while using the way a person would get the job done Venus Element Venus Element can be a New Pounds Reduction System Only for Gals out or develop muscle mass.
This eating plan routine may help individuals preserve enthusiastic, as a consequence of the 236 a variety of dishes, which suggests men and women will not get fed up along with the exact form of bland food stuff they ate prior to go to metabolic cooking official site with all the uninteresting, common body weight reduction packages.Metabolic Cooking will permit folks to be concious of harmful foods and elements. It truly is planning to teach people today on techniques to stop all of these, or substitute them with substantially much healthier choices, to make sure that folks weight loss endeavors are not likely to be sabotaged.
Pretty good post.
car service in chicago il
Magnetic Messaging will be the very pleased development of Bobby Rio and Rob Choose, each of whom are pro relationship advisors. Bobby Rio generously disburses courting knowledge for all by means of interactive platforms, courting journals and internet sites. He’s also the writer of numerous textbooks that espouse the tricks of attracting aspiration ladies and exactly how to magnetic messaging examples properly day them. His men’s life-style web site TSBMag.com is extremely well-liked and it has gained him hundreds of followers within the courting field.
Incredible, your article is fairly remarkable. I have to state that from now your site will grow to be certainly one of my faves. Keeping it heading close friend
photo booth rental
Thanks for sharing us this steps on how to install and setup New Relic on CentOS and RedHat to use with Drupal. https://www.rebelmouse.com/capturehisheartclairecasey/