Anyone familiar with housing affordability in the Washington (DC-VA-MD-WV) metropolitan area is aware that prices have risen strongly relative to incomes in the last decade.
However, a recent Washington Post commentary by Roger K. Lewis both exaggerates the contribution of higher construction costs and misses the principal factor that has driven up the price of housing: more restrictive land-use regulations.
Lewis compares construction costs in the early 1970s to current costs and finds that they are approximately 6 times as high. However, when the R. S. Means construction cost index for locations in the metropolitan area are adjusted for inflation, the increase is more like 15% (1970 to 2007).
Lewis also indicates that construction costs have risen faster than the "relatively flat income curve." In contrast, Census Bureau data indicate that median household incomes in the Washington metropolitan area have increased more than 30% since the early 1970s, after adjustment for inflation. House construction costs are the flatter of the two, not incomes.
While Lewis’ focus is affordable housing, costs in this low income sector are impacted by many of the same factors that drive overall housing affordability (overall house prices relative to incomes).
Lewis does not consider the huge cost increase in the non-construction costs of housing. In the Washington metropolitan area, we have estimated that the land and the regulatory costs for a new house have been driven to more than 5.5 times the level that would be expected in a normal regulatory environment (see the Demographia Residential Land & Regulation Cost Index). The problem is that the restrictive land-use policies, such as the Montgomery County agricultural reserve, similar regulations in other metropolitan area counties and the large lot building restrictions in Loudoun County have driven the price of land up substantially, and with it, the price of housing. We estimate that more restrictive land use regulations have driven the price of a new house up approximately $75,000.
Not surprisingly, Washington’s Median Multiple (median house price divided by median household income) remains more than a third above the 3.0 historic norm, at 4.0, even after the burst of the housing bubble. So long as governments in the Washington, DC area continue to strictly ration land for development, higher than necessary costs will continue to plague both housing affordability and affordable housing.
Comments
50 responses to “Why Housing is So Expensive in Metropolitan Washington”
If your area has urban growth boundaries, you will have affordability problems. That is guaranteed. I don’t know why people cannot accept that. People have to react to over reaching government regulation, and in ways that politicians don’t want. They are told every time, it is ignored every time.
Urban Growth Boundaries are a clear overreach. Taking otherwise developable land out of the market creates shortages. When the market says that farm should be turned into a subdivision, it should become a subdivision. Governments do not understand markets (and have no ability of understanding them) and should be prevented from interfering with them. You end up making an area that should have $20,000 building lots and turning them into $75,000 ones for no good reason.
Plus in the US, UGB’s are likely unconstitutional. Its basically government taking of private property without compensation. That farmer is prevented from profiting from developing his farm into something the market wants. There is no way for the government to pay for that loss because there is no way it could afford it.
Overreaching land regulations are the biggest threat to home ownership in most of the developed world. It is only getting worse. There are no reason for places like Australia to have expensive land, but it does. It is a huge country with plenty of open land but it is stuck with over regulation. There is plenty of land in the Washington DC area. They need to deregulate its development. It would also help if the federal government would move more of its operations out of the area into more affordable locations.
Although I can’t believe the fact with all you staded, I must acknowledge I do really like your way of composing.
Tubal reversal financing
The actors about the expensive housing is well presented and i think if all these reasons are available with the agencies they should do some possible efforts to make it cheaper for the people.
Regards,
Alaczen
This post has helped me to have another perspective. I am researching this topic for a paper I am writing. Your article provided me great insight of my topic.
free cell phone spy software
Great stuff of your stuff, man. I’ve read your stuff before and you’re too awesome. I enjoy what you’ve got here, love what you’re saying and exactly how you say it. You create it entertaining but you just seem to ensure that is stays smart. I can’t wait to see more of your stuff. This is really a fantastic blog.
cell spyware
I didn’t say it didn’t, to be fair. I didn’t say it didn’t, to be fair. I was just disappointed to find so much stomach-meat on the nachos was all. – Hotel di Semarang
This is exactly what I was looking for. After examine a few of the blog posts on your web site now, and I really like your manner of blogging. I really impressed by reading this article.
clubmz reviews
It’s a true face that, construction cost has increased drastically present years. It’s almost 6 times higher when compared to that of 1970’s in Washington. I think that is the reason why more people are migrating to rural areas! read more here
Sudden hike can be a result of development in the cities .. Lot of people migrate to the cities in search of job opportunities, employment, business etc .. Thus resulting in the sudden hike
http://www.leatherfads.com/leather-jacket.aspx
I admire the way you express yourself through writing. Your post is such a refreshing one to read. This is such an interesting and informative article to share with others.But I think it is not enough to give me total knowledge on this subject and so asking you to provide more details on this critical issue.I am waiting for your reply.Calgary home builders
I have been waiting for someone to share these post. This has really made me think and I hope to read more. Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this topic. – toko sepatu online
Really admirable goal you aer contain for working across cultural differences and identities. I hope your work proecss will be improve by the assist of tech. ThanksDigital font
Il s’agit d’un article bien écrit sur ce sujet. J’ai cherché à créer une nouvelle entreprise, ce qui constitue une information précieuse pour m’aider dans ma décision. Merci.Tondeuse moutons
This is an awesome post. No wonder this blog is standing at the top. I don’t know how you get such wonderful articles and contents. I don’t think there is any other blog out there which can compete with this one.Jason Johnson
Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.raise-your-credit-score-yourself
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own blog nowArgan Oil
DC area continue to strictly ration land for development, higher than necessary costs will continue to plague both housing affordability and affordable housing. http://www.kamagrafx.com/
I think you have a great choice for inspiring and entertaining people. You have tons of great experience that will beneficial for others.Andrea McKay
You actually make it appear so easy with your performance but I find this affair to be actually something which I think I would never comprehend. It seems too complex and extremely broad for meSharon Poole
I really like this type of interesting articles keep it u.Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. It contains truly informationInnentueren
Wow! I really appreciate the thought that you put into this article. This topic newway has been something I have been looking into for a few hours and your post is one of the best I have read.term paper writer
I always hated geography! But after reading your blog I changed my views. geography is not so bad!
http://www.venkotech.com
I agree with what people have to say on your work. Those are really very beautiful paintings from you. Never saw anything creative like this. Would love to see you making more paintings like this. http://www.getnewsheadlines.com
It was a time when online shopping in Pakistan was not considered safe due to the fake transactions of the credit cards. Now a days, cash on delivery service by various couriers has made it easy to buy online in Pakistan.
http://www.sevenstarwatches.com/
http://www.sevenstarwatches.com/
_aVisit: tu van dau tu nuoc ngoai, cong bo thuc pham, thiet ke website ban hang, thanh lap cong ty, dang ky nhan hieu, cong bo luu hanh my pham…
This post has helped me to have another perspective. I am researching this topic for a paper I am writing. Your article provided me great insight of my topic.toko jilbab online | rias pengantin wisuda muslimah
Why would we want to buy a house in a metro area? Unless I’m a twenty-something trying to live the life on the edge, I would never settle at a metropolitan area, for me, the suburbs is a lot more comfortable and the community is much more tight, not to mention it is a lot more quieter too.
http://chordsworld.com/demi-lovato-made-in-the-usa-chords/
Wow this topic is really fresh. may be I will choose this as my project topic. I love the way you write the article. 😀
Online MBA
I want to buy a new house this year but the price is very high, I can buy a new once, hope the price will reduce soon.
Ghe giam doc
price hike in petroleum sector is a terrible nation is going through! Need to find another source of energy which is affordable by a common man and ofcourse should be environment friendly
http://www.ifeel.edu.in
Certainly a fantastic piece of work … It has relevant information. Thanks for posting this. Your blog is so interesting and very informative.Thanks sharing. Definitely a great piece of work Thanks for your work.truly rich club
Thanks for your great article friend, i get new information, new ideas to do something…..I rally appreciate your work….navigate to this website to grab more knowledge….keep posting and sharing….GOOD LUCK…..
That’s pretty powerful stuff. I like the way your logic follows, and how you’re able to put it into words with such a powerful post! I am enthralled….this page anchor provides you more uesful info….
It is very rare to get such wonderful post over internet. I was searching for like this post only which contains valuable information on Housing. Anyways, after some time i have to buy a new home and hope that prices will reduce quickly till that time. Thanks.
community housing
With the MOTOR TREND Certified Pre-Owned program, two of the biggest automotive brands, MOTOR TREND and EasyCare, guarantee that you will drive away from the dealership confident – and stay confident – in your pre-owned vehicle. MOTOR TREND Certified Vehicles is the first certified pre-owned program to be specifically developed to deliver a superior consumer experience from purchase through ownership.
Triangle Chiropractor Austin Texas, is a health facility that provides professional and empathetic treatment to its patients. No matter you are suffering from a pinched nerve or some muscle spasm, Chiropractors Austin Texas exactly know your treatment.
While Lewis’ focus is affordable housing, costs in this low income sector are impacted by many of the same factors that drive overall housing affordability (overall house prices relative to incomes).
SEO Services Company
This is something which I was searching from long back. Thank you for sharing such an informative postkamagra oral jelly
I’m glad I fоund thіs web site, I couldn’t find anу knowledge оn thіs matter prior to.Also operate а site аnd іf уou arе evеr interested іn doіng ѕоmе visitor writing fоr mе іf pоsѕiblе feel free tо lеt mе know, іm alwауs lооk fоr people tо check оut mу web site. baju busana batik
This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can Get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect! free vectors
World without war would be a fun thing. There are many people who are very happy with a lot of peace that can be Potenzmittelkaufen deutschland
Lewis compares construction costs in the early 1970s to current costs and finds that they are approximately 6 times as high. However, when the R. S. Means construction cost index for locations in the metropolitan area are adjusted for inflation, the increase is more like 15% (1970 to 2007).
Most Popular Websites
I truly appreciate this post.The design of the home is very beautiful. I am very lucky to be able to come to see your how to buy a research paper online .Keep up the good work.
There are many Gaming site.But interesting games like minecraft
are rare. This site provide funny games for gamers.
This site provide funny games for gamers.
business school personal statement
Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. It contains truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing. Looking forward to more minnesota web design
That highly thorough and also useful book exclusively details restorative yoga exercise exercises including powerful postures, pranayama, mudras and also yoga procedures worthy alleviate daily conditions.YATAN Pilates Remedy details more than 50 typical problems, across each of the programs on the entire body, telling you these individuals from your yogic and also Ayurvedic points of views.
Yoga Books
Yoga Books Australia
Sinusitis can be infection with the fresh air cavities inside pathways with the nose.
Sinusitis Treatment
Our commitment is to provide our customers the best shopping experience possible with our personalized customer service at a safe and secure environment. We proudly stand behind the quality of products that we sell because we believe in providing our customers the best quality and affordable fine watches together with excellent customer service
http://7star.pk/prices-drop
http://7star.pk/27_bonito-watches
In neuro-scientific search engine optimisation (Search engine marketing), a crucial part could be the using of key phrases. They are the words and phrases that searchers really type in the search engines. web hosting lexington ky