Americans have their “American Dream” of home ownership. Australians go one step further. They have a “Great Australian Dream” of home ownership. This was all part of a culture that celebrated its egalitarian ethos. Yet, to an even greater degree than in the United States, the “Dream” is in the process of being extinguished. It all started and is the worst in Sydney.
Sydney is Australia’s largest urban area, having passed Melbourne in the last half of the 19th century. With an urban area population of approximately 3.6 million, Sydney leads Melbourne by nearly 300,000.
The “Great Australian Dream” in Sydney: Sydney incubated and perfected the Great Australian Dream. New housing was built in all directions from the central business district. The most expensive was built to the east and north, while the least expensive – the bungalows and other modest detached houses – rose principally to the west and the south. Western Sydney is the culmination of the Great Australian Dream for perhaps more middle and lower middle income households than any other place in the nation.
Of course, Western Sydney was not planned in the radical sense of the word currently used by contemporary urbanists. In fact, most have little more regard for Western Sydney than for the shantytowns of Jakarta or Manila. Yet, the people of Western Sydney, like the people of countless modest suburban areas around the world, are proud of their communities and of their homes.
Rationing Land, Blowing Out Land Prices: About three decades ago, Sydney embarked upon what was to become one of the world’s strongest “smart growth” programs (called “urban consolidation” in Australia). Aimed at concentrating population closer to the core, urban consolidation sought to restrict and even prohibit new housing on the urban fringe. Sydney developed its own equivalent of the famous Portland urban growth boundary. The result is that every land owner knows whether or not their property can be developed, and the favored understandably take advantage by charging whatever price the highly constrained market will bear.
Reserve Bank of Australia research indicates that the price of raw land – Sydney urban fringe land for building a house that has not yet been fitted with infrastructure (sewers, water, streets, etc.) has now risen to a price of about $190,000 for a one-eighth acre lot. In the days before smart growth, the land would cost about $1,000. Needless to say, adding an unnecessary nearly $190,000 plus margins to the price of a house makes housing less affordable.
But even where development is nominally allowed, government restrictions make building almost impossible. For years the state government has promised to “release” land for new housing on the western fringe. Yet despite announcement and re-announcement, there have been interminable delays.
Destroying Housing Affordability: As a result, Sydney is now the second most expensive major housing market in the six nations in our Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey, trailing only Vancouver. Sydney’s Median Multiple (the median house price divided by the median household income) is now 8.3. It should be close to the historic norm of 3.0 or less. Indeed, if land prices had risen with inflation from before urban consolidation, Sydney’s Median Multiple would be less than 3.0. As a result, households entering the housing market can expect to pay nearly three times as much for their houses than was the case before. This will lead to an inevitably lower standard of living compared to what would have otherwise been.
Forcing Density: Urban consolidation is destroying not only housing affordability, but also the character of Sydney itself. Sydney is an urban area of low density suburbs. It is also an urban area of high rise living. These two housing forms have combined with one of the world’s most attractive geographical settings to create an attractive and livable urban area.
The planners, empowered by the state of New South Wales government, are changing all of that. From the suburbs of Western Sydney to the attractive and more affluent North Shore suburbs, high-rise residential buildings are being thrust upon detached housing neighborhoods. One of Sydney’s great strengths is that the urban area has many local government areas (municipalities), empowering local democracy. These local governments have done their best to resist the state government densification mandates, in response to opposition from their citizens.
Raw Exercise of Power: One of Sydney’s greatest weaknesses is that the state government exercises undue control over the municipalities and is using its power to “shoe-horn” high density into places where it makes no sense. High density is fine in the Toney Eastern suburbs, but has no place where detached housing is the rule. Unfortunately, the planners seem to presume communities with detached housing have no character worth salvaging.
Urban Consolidation: Infrastructure Costs: Further, there is an inherent assumption that densification has no costs. The planners routinely exaggerate the cost of providing infrastructure on the urban fringes (failing, for example, to understand that much infrastructure is included in the price of the house, without government involvement). However, the infrastructure built for lower density detached housing is not sufficient for higher densities. As a result, there have been sewer overflows in densifying areas. Huge expenditures have been made for sewer upgrades. Tony Recsei, president of Save Our Suburbs, a community organization seeking to limit inappropriate densification, blamed recent power failures on an electricity infrastructure that was not built for high density in an April 7 Daily Telegraph letter, noting that “Cram in more people and overloading must result. That should not be too hard for people to understand.”
Greater Traffic Congestion: And, of course, insufficient road expansion has been undertaken to accommodate the inevitable intensification of traffic congestion. The planners like to say that higher densities mean less traffic. In fact virtually all of the evidence, throughout the first world, indicates that more intense traffic congestion is associated with higher densities.
Sydney is no exception. The average one-way work trip now takes 34 minutes, which equals that of America’s largest urban area, New York, which has more than five times the population and the land area as well as the longest travel time of any major urban area in the nation. Sydney’s planners delight in comparisons with Los Angeles, frequently suggesting that their regulations are necessary to ensure that Sydney does not “sprawl” as much as Los Angeles. Actually Sydney sprawls considerably more in relation to its population. The Los Angeles urban area is a full one-third more dense than the Sydney urban area. And despite the fact that nearly half of the planned Los Angeles freeway system was not built, Angelinos spend one hour less each week getting to work each than Sydneysiders. Even in Atlanta, with a pathetic freeway system little better than Sydney’s and one-third Sydney’s density, people spend an hour less commuting to and from work every two weeks and spend less total time traveling than in Sydney.
The Economic Cost: There may also be an economic cost. Bernard Salt – perhaps Australia’s leading demographer – has predicted that Melbourne will overtake Sydney in population by 2028. Moreover, there has been substantial domestic migration from New South Wales to Queensland. At current growth rates this could lead the Brisbane-Gold Coast region being larger than Sydney by mid-century. Salt blames Sydney’s declining fortunes on its overly expensive housing.
Sydney: World-Class City Status Threatened? Research in the United States has associated restrictive land use regulation with lower levels of employment growth in US metropolitan areas. In a more colorful finding, Australia’s Access Economics characterized the economy of New South as “so sick that it is at risk of adoption by Angelina Jolie.” A few decades ago, the English economy was referred to as the “sick man of Europe.” Sydney may well be on its way to becoming the “sick man of Australia.”
Wendell Cox is a Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointed to three terms on the Los Angeles County Transportation Commission by Mayor Tom Bradley. He is the author of “War on the Dream: How Anti-Sprawl Policy Threatens the Quality of Life.
Comments
59 responses to “Sydney: From World City to “Sick Man” of Australia”
It’s remarkable that Wendell Cox can both advocate total freedom to develop land into detached single-family housing (an increase in density from pastoral to urban) and also advocate suburban fiefdoms zoning out rights to develop a single-family lot into a multi-family lot.
Wendell Cox only approves of development when it’s horizontal, which benefits only one class of people – the land speculators – and not the small homeowner who would love to help out his community by subdividing his property into the higher-density 3-4 story housing that has been the natural scale of things for all of urban history.
While I agree that higher densities have a negative impact instead of a positive impact, (the worst kind of urban environment emerging is dense sprawl) they are the outcome of higher demand. Cox points out that land use controls increase housing prices at the urban fringe, but the policies he supports to artificially maintain low densities have exactly the same effect: they make housing within the urban core unaffordable.
How he can praise the “democratic” land use controls of established suburban communities and denounce the “planners” of the regional authorities baffles me.
Yes, higher densities will result in more traffic. The reason for that is that the traffic system is irrational, in other words the traffic planners failed. There are ways to upgrade suburban cities to make them compatible with naturally increasing densities. But why bother to keep up with the market when you can just zone out all density increases and let developers soak up all the excess demand?
Emergent Urbanism
http://mathieuhelie.wordpress.com
As long as people keep reproducing and urban areas keep growing, we will always have this problem … and if not this, then the alternative is spreading out into unspoilt natural areas and destroying them. Economics (and its bedmate greed) are creating this dilemma, where governments don’t want to expand, but the alternative will also displease an important section of society and go against important rules. You don’t need to dust off the imaginary passport and take out travel insurance to see this happening in other areas of the world. I’m not disagreeing … just saying that it is difficult all round because of factors beyond the government’s control.
A few decades ago, the English economy was referred to as the “sick man of Europe.” Sydney may well be on its way to becoming the “sick man of Australia.
This is great post, and I’m glad to see you sharing it with your readers.
http://australia.xpatjobs.com/
One of Sydney’s greatest weaknesses is that the state government exercises undue control over the municipalities and is using its power to “shoe-horn” high density into places where it makes no sense. High density is fine in the Toney Eastern suburbs, but has no place where detached housing is the rule.
camera digital
Everything is very open and very clear clarification of issues. It contains truly facts. Your website is very valuable. Thanks for sharing. Camara Hiperbarica | Renta De Camionetas
This is a good post. This post give truly quality information.I’m definitely going to look into it.Really very useful tips are provided here.thank you so much.Keep up the good works.
sexy lingerie
But even where development is nominally allowed, government restrictions make building almost impossible. For years the state government has promised to “release” land for new housing on the western fringe. Yet despite announcement and re-announcement, there have been interminable delays.
Seattle Wedding Shows
Sydney is a great place to live. The environment is superb and also it has a nice and cool weather all the time.
mole removal home remedy
It’s best suited time to create some strategies for that potential also it is time getting happy. i have look at this educational article and if I could I desire to advise you some fascinating concerns or advice. possibly you can create subsequent content articles referring to this article. I desire to look at even much more concerns about it!%%%
Renault CAN Clip*
Lexia 3*
Lexia 3 interface*
Sydney is no exception. The average one-way work trip now takes 34 minutes, which equals that of America’s largest urban area, New York, which has more than five times the population and the land area as well as the longest travel time of any major urban area in the nation.
cell phone listening 🙂
This is my first time at your blog and I’ve really enjoyed looking around. I will come back again in the future to check out some of the other articles. pet urns
That is really amazing dear buddy keep it up and say all is well. Dass
As long as people keep reproducing and urban areas keep growing, we will always have this problem … and if not this, then the alternative is spreading out into unspoilt natural areas and destroying them
affiliate program | malaysia affiliate program | affiliate program malaysia | affiliate malaysia | affiliate program in malaysia
The planners like to say that higher densities mean less traffic. In fact virtually all of the evidence, throughout the first world, indicates that more intense traffic congestion is associated with higher densities. cell phone spy software
I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike other blogs I have read which are really not that good.Thanks a lot! Price of Nokia
This is a good post. This post give truly quality information.I’m definitely going to look into it.Really very useful tips are provided here.thank you so much.Keep up the good works. renta de autobuses
Rationing Land, Blowing Out Land Prices: About three decades ago, Sydney embarked upon what was to become one of the world’s strongest “smart growth” programs (called “urban consolidation” in Australia). Aimed at concentrating population closer to the core, urban consolidation sought to restrict and even prohibit new housing on the urban fringe. Sydney developed its own equivalent of the famous Portland urban growth boundary. The result is that every land owner knows whether or not their property can be developed, and the favored understandably take advantage by charging whatever price the highly constrained market will bear.. Galaxy S3 Price Pakistan
i have enjoyed this great information so much. This was really very interesting and helpful to read. I cant wait to read more from this site.buy backlinks | high pr backlinks | High pagerank backlinks | buy high pagerank backlinks | buy high pr backlinks | high pr backlink
We are a bankruptcy judge and a bankruptcy lawyer and deal with financial problems all the time.Credit Counseling. business information
It is great to have the opportunity to read a good quality article with useful information on topics that plenty are interested on.I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your future updates tutorial designer
I found your website in the search engines and also study a number of ones other posts. I simply added one to the The search engines Reports Reader. Sustain the excellent do the job Expect studying much more from anyone in the future….Samsung Galaxy S3
By the way I am going to save this blog to my favorites travling location
Western Sydney is the culmination of the Great Australian Dream for perhaps more middle and lower middle income households than any other place in the nation. clubmz e-spy
As long as people keep reproducing and urban areas keep growing, we will always have this problem … and if not this, then the alternative is spreading small loans
Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointedphen375 ingredients
To and from work every two weeks and spend less total time traveling than in Sydney.http://people.bu.edu/zackcost/
From work every two weeks and spend less total time traveling than in Sydneydealsextra
Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles orlando computer repair
Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointedRelationship Tips by Ovulation Cal
Less commuting to and from work every two weeks and spend less total time traveling than in Sydney.Relationship Issues With Mongeat Tips
National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointedMongeat Tips Tips
National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointeCar insurance Denverr
Well, the commodity is in fact the sweetest affair on this accompanying issue. I fit in with your abstracts and will thirstily attending advanced to your accessible updates.
womens-health-guide.com
Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles andBoca Raton CPA
This was all part of a culture that celebrated its egalitarian ethos. The IT Experts
A few decades ago, the English economy was referred to as the “sick man of Europe.” Sydney may well be on its way to becoming the “sick man of Australia.”IT Articles
A few decades ago, the English economy was referred to as the “sick man of Europe.” Sydney may well be on its way to becoming the “sick man of Australia.”Submit Articles
A few decades ago, the English economy was referred to as the “sick man of Europe.” Sydney may well be on its way to becoming the “sick man of Australia.”Computer Resources
from work every two weeks and spend less total time traveling than in Sydney.Boca Raton Accountant
the startup tips to learn the most powerful BitKinex features faster.Boca Raton Accountant
The average round trip work now takes 34 minutes, which is equal to the largest urban area in the United States, New York, which has more than five times the population Raspberry ketons
I am have been studying this topic for a long time. You have provided great information in you post and some things I have not seen Health Blogroll
: There may also be an economic cost. Bernard Salt – perhaps Australia’s leading demographer – has predicted that Melbourne will overtake Sydney in population by 2028. Moreover, there has been substantial domestic migration from New South Wales to Queensland. At current growth rates this could lead the Brisbane-Gold Coast region being larger than Sydney write my paper
you know the same kind of destruction was happened in San Fransisco too… http://www.tajweddingservices.co.uk/asian-wedding-venues.html
The Economic Cost: There may also be an economic cost. Bernard Salt – perhaps Australia’s leading demographer – has predicted that Melbourne will overtake Sydney in population by 2028. Moreover, there has been substantial domestic migration from New South Wales to Queensland. At current growth rates this could lead the Brisbane-Gold Coast region being larger than Sydney by mid-century. Salt blames Sydney’s declining fortunes Mehandi Designs
This post give truly quality information.I’m definitely going to look into it.Really very useful tips are provided here.thank you so much.Keep up the good works.
ticketing system australia
A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. self catering accommodation in Hazyview
thank you for sharing this useful information and i will let know my friends as well.
tu van dau tu nuoc ngoai, cong bo thuc pham, thiet ke website,
you should check more Springfield Hack before you sayng it .
I found this informative and interesting blog so i think so its very useful and knowledge able.I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. Welsh Rugby shirts
Its my first visit to your blog and i am very happy that this blog is a great soure to keep ourselfs up to date. I bokmarked it so that i can visit again.
Horror movies
I really appreciate the points you made. I don’t think I’ve actually thought about it in that way. I can really appreciate how you approached the subject matter and what you said really gave me a new perspective. small business web design
I was waiting for this type article and I have gained some useful information from this site. Thanks for sharing this information. buy quality backlink
pr5 backlink
high Pagerank Backlinks
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks! SEO packages
manual social bookmarking
buy quality backlink
I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors for this blog. I will bookmark this page for my future reference. Thanks! SEO packages
manual social bookmarking
buy quality backlink
A treasure to get all exclusive details of Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and the Congress party. http://pressbrief.in/ contains all news, articles, videos and press releases in connection with these leaders. Sonia Gandhi
I really appreciate the aspects you designed. I do not think I have actually considered about it in that way. I can really appreciate how you approached the subject and what you said really offered me a new perspective. http://www.nectarclaims.co.uk
an April 7 Daily Telegraph letter, noting that “Cram in more people and overloading must result. That should not be too hard for people to understand.” enhancement reviews Plus